1
00:00:34,420 --> 00:00:41,890
Hello and welcome, everyone, to this colloquium on Gods and Robots, Smith's machines and ancient dreams of technology.

2
00:00:41,890 --> 00:00:47,590
And apologies for our delay this evening because of a technical hitch with YouTube.

3
00:00:47,590 --> 00:00:53,870
My name is John Textualists and I'm the director of Oxford Institute for Ethics in.

4
00:00:53,870 --> 00:01:04,040
How would the ancient Greeks relevant to our efforts to grapple with the contemporary challenges posed by robots and A.I. to discuss this question?

5
00:01:04,040 --> 00:01:08,450
I'm delighted to welcome our main speaker this evening, Adrian Mayer,

6
00:01:08,450 --> 00:01:16,010
who is a research scholar in the classics department and the History and Philosophy of Science programme at Stanford University.

7
00:01:16,010 --> 00:01:22,820
Adrian is also the author of a marvellous book on this topic entitled Gods, Robots, Gods and Robots, Myths,

8
00:01:22,820 --> 00:01:28,460
Machines and Ancient Dreams of Technology, published by Princeton University Press in twenty eighteen.

9
00:01:28,460 --> 00:01:36,890
Welcome, Adrian. Thank you. I'm also very pleased to welcome to distinguished commentators Chardy Botched Zimmer, who is Helen,

10
00:01:36,890 --> 00:01:44,970
a reconciling distinguished service professor of Classics and the programme in gender studies at the University of Chicago.

11
00:01:44,970 --> 00:01:53,340
The most recent publication is The Aeneid, a new translation published by Random House last year, and Armand Dango,

12
00:01:53,340 --> 00:02:00,030
who is professor of classical languages and literature at Oxford University and a fellow of Jesus College.

13
00:02:00,030 --> 00:02:08,900
His books include Socrates in Love The Making of a Philosopher, published by Bloomsbury in Twenty Eighteen.

14
00:02:08,900 --> 00:02:19,860
Welcome to you both. Now, at a quite fundamental level, the ancient Greeks are relevant because it challenges a very soft conception as human beings,

15
00:02:19,860 --> 00:02:24,800
a soft conception that has been shaped by Greek thought.

16
00:02:24,800 --> 00:02:29,660
According to Plato and Aristotle, just to pick up two random ancient Greeks,

17
00:02:29,660 --> 00:02:39,980
we humans are essentially rational in nature and our personal flourishing lies in the cultivation and exercise of our rational faculties.

18
00:02:39,980 --> 00:02:43,280
This self conception still resonates today.

19
00:02:43,280 --> 00:02:51,770
For example, it's widespread in the notion of human dignity that plays such an important role, for example, in thinking about human rights,

20
00:02:51,770 --> 00:03:03,550
even if, of course, it has taken a battering over the centuries from various forms of naturalism and scepticism, some scientistic and postmodern.

21
00:03:03,550 --> 00:03:09,310
I, however, confronts us uniquely with the prospect of artificial intelligence,

22
00:03:09,310 --> 00:03:17,920
we can do things that normally require the exercise of human and things like making a medical diagnosis,

23
00:03:17,920 --> 00:03:26,880
predicting the likelihood that a criminal offence, deciding whether credit should be extended to someone.

24
00:03:26,880 --> 00:03:36,990
But beyond this general point, Adrian's book reveals that the Greeks are like us in addressing the challenge of robots and AI in two ways.

25
00:03:36,990 --> 00:03:43,530
First, that there were actual examples of automata to guide their reflections.

26
00:03:43,530 --> 00:03:54,290
Like the philosopher, engineer and friend of Plato, Qantas caused a sensation, apparently with this mechanical flying Darth.

27
00:03:54,290 --> 00:04:02,030
But second, and more importantly, because of the presence of Automator in many of the ancient myths from the bronze giant,

28
00:04:02,030 --> 00:04:09,730
tell us to the ambiguous figure of Pandora. And like us, the Greeks did,

29
00:04:09,730 --> 00:04:21,160
between fear and hope in the face of the imagined technological advances that replicated or surpassed human powers of reason,

30
00:04:21,160 --> 00:04:31,180
as Adrian puts it in her book and I quote, The unsettling oscillation between techno nightmares and grand futuristic dreams is timeless.

31
00:04:31,180 --> 00:04:39,790
It is with us now, and it is present in the ancient Greeks understanding of humanity's drive to transcend itself.

32
00:04:39,790 --> 00:04:47,020
Sometimes to strive to transcendence takes a noble form. All too often, however, it is a source of fear and dread.

33
00:04:47,020 --> 00:04:54,370
And it is surely instructive for us today grappling with the power of big tech and A.I. enabled government

34
00:04:54,370 --> 00:05:02,500
surveillance to subvert democracy in various ways to observe that many of the most famous ancient Automator,

35
00:05:02,500 --> 00:05:15,750
Telos and Pandora included were created as expressions of absolute arbitrary power, whether a vengeful God like Zoosk or a tyrant like King Bynum's.

36
00:05:15,750 --> 00:05:18,780
So I'm very much looking forward to this discussion.

37
00:05:18,780 --> 00:05:26,760
Please remember that there was a Q&A session towards the end, so feel free to put your questions in the chat box on YouTube.

38
00:05:26,760 --> 00:05:32,460
But I have now very great pleasure in turning over to you.

39
00:05:32,460 --> 00:05:37,950
Thank you, John. I'm so honoured to be invited to this colloquium and I ethics.

40
00:05:37,950 --> 00:05:48,420
I'm really looking forward to talking with you and shot in Armaan and everyone else about how automatons were first imagined in classical antiquity.

41
00:05:48,420 --> 00:05:56,970
And for my book I started with a question who first imagined robots, automatons, artificial intelligence,

42
00:05:56,970 --> 00:06:03,300
replicants and historians of technology usually traced the first self Drizzt

43
00:06:03,300 --> 00:06:10,380
driven self driving machines to the Middle Ages using clockwork mechanisms.

44
00:06:10,380 --> 00:06:12,810
But we know that, as you just mentioned,

45
00:06:12,810 --> 00:06:24,660
arthritis was able to make self a self moving bird in the fourth century B.C. And some philosophers of science, to my surprise,

46
00:06:24,660 --> 00:06:31,200
have argued that no one in antiquity could even imagine automatons before the technology existed,

47
00:06:31,200 --> 00:06:40,020
which is seems patently counterintuitive because where does innovation come from, if not from imagining things that don't already exist?

48
00:06:40,020 --> 00:06:53,820
And I do have some images tonight. So if we could have the first slide Huli that just shows the book and the two automatons

49
00:06:53,820 --> 00:07:00,390
and artificial entities that I'm that I'm going to be talking about tonight.

50
00:07:00,390 --> 00:07:06,630
I wondered, was it possible? I think we'll go to the first slide.

51
00:07:06,630 --> 00:07:09,960
Well, you can you can do that.

52
00:07:09,960 --> 00:07:19,920
Was it possible that the idea, the concepts of making artificial life automatons and even I could have appeared much earlier in history,

53
00:07:19,920 --> 00:07:26,220
could people in antiquity actually imagine such things before technology ever made them possible?

54
00:07:26,220 --> 00:07:33,120
And it does turn out that more than two thousand five hundred years ago, in the time of Homer,

55
00:07:33,120 --> 00:07:42,570
some vivid Greek myths did envision how one might fabricate artificial life robots and other synthetic beings.

56
00:07:42,570 --> 00:07:50,190
And these myths emerge long before the technological innovations of the Hellenistic era,

57
00:07:50,190 --> 00:07:59,090
beginning in the fourth century B.C. that I mentioned earlier, long before that.

58
00:07:59,090 --> 00:08:09,860
People were imagining making artificial life, and I know this is a rather strange exercise for a very future oriented group,

59
00:08:09,860 --> 00:08:22,490
but I'm inviting you to consider imaginative ideas about creating artificial life explored in mythic stories from more than two millennia ago.

60
00:08:22,490 --> 00:08:28,640
And these consider these myths. Think of them as thought experiments.

61
00:08:28,640 --> 00:08:35,310
I think it's fun to call them the first first ever science fiction tales.

62
00:08:35,310 --> 00:08:44,360
And now the next slide, please. These artificial forms of life were described as made, not born,

63
00:08:44,360 --> 00:08:51,170
so that we know they were imagined as manufactured, not reproduced biologically or naturally.

64
00:08:51,170 --> 00:09:00,370
So we're not talking about just lifeless objects or inert matter that was brought to life by a magical spell or a God's command.

65
00:09:00,370 --> 00:09:04,400
I mean, there are stories like that. Every culture has stories like that.

66
00:09:04,400 --> 00:09:15,170
I'm talking today about entities that were imagined as products of what we might call biotechnology or life through craft.

67
00:09:15,170 --> 00:09:24,050
So these were technological products and they were constructed by gods using familiar tools and materials and methods of the day.

68
00:09:24,050 --> 00:09:30,440
But because the makers were gods, they achieved awesome results.

69
00:09:30,440 --> 00:09:39,620
The next slide, please. And so today we'll start with the very first robot to walk the earth and talk about mythology.

70
00:09:39,620 --> 00:09:48,540
For us, this is tell us the giant bronze automaton made by the God of invention and technology.

71
00:09:48,540 --> 00:09:53,990
Hephaestus the blacksmith God. This is a very ancient oral tradition.

72
00:09:53,990 --> 00:09:59,060
And it was first written down in about 700 B.C. around the time of Homer.

73
00:09:59,060 --> 00:10:09,740
And this famous ancient Vaisse painting by the Talos painter shows Talos as a man constructed out of bronze.

74
00:10:09,740 --> 00:10:22,850
Telos was a killer robot. He was given by the gods to his son, King Minos, to defend the kingdom of Crete from invaders.

75
00:10:22,850 --> 00:10:27,110
Telos was able to march around the island three times a day.

76
00:10:27,110 --> 00:10:37,430
His task was to spot invaders and then he could pick up boulders and hurl them at approaching ships to try and sink the ships.

77
00:10:37,430 --> 00:10:45,620
But tell us had other capabilities in close combat, he could heat his metallic bodies made of bronze,

78
00:10:45,620 --> 00:10:57,140
heat his body red hot, and then grab the victims and crush them to his chest and roast them along.

79
00:10:57,140 --> 00:11:05,890
Next slide, please. Yes, these capabilities were shown on ancient coins from Crete,

80
00:11:05,890 --> 00:11:13,600
you see him throwing rocks or boulders and the bronze mirror, he is crushing some victims.

81
00:11:13,600 --> 00:11:19,450
Remarkably, we even know something about the automatons, InnerWorkings.

82
00:11:19,450 --> 00:11:23,710
And I think these details confirm his technological origins.

83
00:11:23,710 --> 00:11:35,860
Tell us, had a single tube or artery running from his head to his foot, but instead of blood, iCore is what pulsed in that conduit or tube.

84
00:11:35,860 --> 00:11:40,210
And iCore was the mysterious life force of the gods.

85
00:11:40,210 --> 00:11:48,070
That's what made them immortal. This entire river system was sealed with a bronze bolt on his ankle.

86
00:11:48,070 --> 00:11:58,000
So tell us, does it really fit? The basic definition of a robot is a self moving android as innerworkings as a power source,

87
00:11:58,000 --> 00:12:06,040
and he interacts with this environment and tell us was featured in the Greek myth about Jason and the Argonauts they encountered.

88
00:12:06,040 --> 00:12:15,010
Tell us when they tried to drop anchor in the rest after gaining the Golden Fleece.

89
00:12:15,010 --> 00:12:22,760
Next slide, please. And this scene is from the vintage cult movie Jason and the Argonauts from nineteen sixty three.

90
00:12:22,760 --> 00:12:32,270
Maybe some of you are familiar with it, a highly recommended just really stop motion animation.

91
00:12:32,270 --> 00:12:41,300
And I actually I like to talk about movies when I'm talking about Greek myths because they're after all, they're all cultural dreams in the myth.

92
00:12:41,300 --> 00:12:44,240
Jason, the Argonauts were doomed to become the victims of tell us.

93
00:12:44,240 --> 00:12:52,640
But luckily for them, the powerful sorceress media was able to save them from tell us.

94
00:12:52,640 --> 00:13:02,300
She's a resourceful and clever which media figured out how to destroy, neutralise and kill the bronze robot.

95
00:13:02,300 --> 00:13:08,330
And she used, I think it's interesting, a combination of persuasion and technology to do that.

96
00:13:08,330 --> 00:13:17,300
Media was able to convince Telos that someday he would die and then she promised that she could make him immortal, make him immortal,

97
00:13:17,300 --> 00:13:29,210
but only if he would allow them to remove the vital bolt on his on his ankle and unaware of his own nature, telling them that.

98
00:13:29,210 --> 00:13:42,540
Next slide, please. The D.A. unsealed the bolt so that the automatons power source, the iCore, would bleed out completely and that is what killed him.

99
00:13:42,540 --> 00:13:48,030
The remarkable idea of using a tool to dismantle tell us.

100
00:13:48,030 --> 00:13:55,320
That's another very ancient idea in the myth. And we know it goes back at least to the fifth century B.C. because we have these paintings

101
00:13:55,320 --> 00:14:04,080
like this one from about 440 B.C. that showed Jason actually using a tool to remove the bolt,

102
00:14:04,080 --> 00:14:09,900
the robot's weak point on his ankle and the robot's power source, iCore.

103
00:14:09,900 --> 00:14:16,920
We hear that it flowed out like molten lead and Telos collapses and topples over.

104
00:14:16,920 --> 00:14:29,700
I think all these details from the myth and the artwork emphasise that Telos was not only made with technology, but he was destroyed.

105
00:14:29,700 --> 00:14:36,930
So tell us was imagined as a metallic automaton, but with some human features.

106
00:14:36,930 --> 00:14:43,740
So he's kind of envisioned as a kind of cyborg, a machine human hybrid.

107
00:14:43,740 --> 00:14:53,040
The techno wizard media was able to guess that TALOS might have developed or had some humanlike desires and she played on that.

108
00:14:53,040 --> 00:15:00,720
For example, TALOS fear, death, he wished to be immortal and tell us could be persuaded and fooled by Medea.

109
00:15:00,720 --> 00:15:05,760
More humanoid features that Mediaa could exploit.

110
00:15:05,760 --> 00:15:14,250
Tell us was a fearsome machine then. But his human aspects also made him a sympathetic figure in antiquity.

111
00:15:14,250 --> 00:15:25,980
Today, psychologists try to figure out why. Why do we tend to anthropomorphise robots and feel empathy for them as though they were human?

112
00:15:25,980 --> 00:15:38,370
We do seem to be hardwired to bestow emotions on things that somehow seem alive to us and of interest to those who work in AI and robotics.

113
00:15:38,370 --> 00:15:52,800
Studies do show that empathy is especially likely for robots and A.I. if the entity has a name and a back story about their creation, as TALOS did.

114
00:15:52,800 --> 00:16:08,610
Next slide, please. A famous modern example of that, some of you might remember the the Stanley Kubrick film, 2001, A Space Odyssey from 1968,

115
00:16:08,610 --> 00:16:17,910
another cult movie, the iconic scene when the astronaut Dave is destroying the spaceships artificial intelligence computer.

116
00:16:17,910 --> 00:16:27,120
Hal and Hal seems most human when he's being deactivated by the astronaut as Hal is dying.

117
00:16:27,120 --> 00:16:34,860
He starts to tell his name and he begins to recite memories from his childhood.

118
00:16:34,860 --> 00:16:46,290
And this evokes sympathy in the audience. Well, in the 1963 film Jason in the Afternoons, US doesn't really have any facial expressions.

119
00:16:46,290 --> 00:16:57,300
The Bronze Robot in the movie. But the animation sequence manages to suggest his personality and intellect in the bronze giant.

120
00:16:57,300 --> 00:17:09,420
Next slide, please. And in that poignant movie scene, as his life force is bleeding out, the great robot struggles to breathe.

121
00:17:09,420 --> 00:17:15,690
You see, on the left there, he clutches his throat while his bronze body cracks and crumbles.

122
00:17:15,690 --> 00:17:25,560
And the modern audience feels pity for the helpless automaton and human qualities are what make the robots destruction feel tragic to us.

123
00:17:25,560 --> 00:17:35,310
And just like in antiquity, people felt sympathy for the robot who was tricked and killed while simply doing his job.

124
00:17:35,310 --> 00:17:45,780
And so in the ancient Vaisse painting there in the centre two thousand five hundred years ago, the dying bronze Talos is humanised, his arms are limp.

125
00:17:45,780 --> 00:17:55,200
He's falling backwards as as he's dying and his eyes are rolling back.

126
00:17:55,200 --> 00:18:07,960
And I think what is even more striking and rare, the ancient artist has painted a teardrop falling from the robot's eye.

127
00:18:07,960 --> 00:18:12,080
Well, that ancient idea of an automaton guard.

128
00:18:12,080 --> 00:18:21,530
Cast in human form, like us, able to defend against invaders that continued to capture people's imagination in the Middle Ages.

129
00:18:21,530 --> 00:18:38,020
Next slide, please. As you may know, Leonardo da Vinci designed a life sized robotic knight in armour in fourteen ninety five, you see on the left.

130
00:18:38,020 --> 00:18:49,630
And a century later, that idea was taken up by the poet Edmund Spencer in his epic poem written in fifty ninety six,

131
00:18:49,630 --> 00:18:58,120
Spencer retooled that bronze robot Talos from Greek myth as The Iron Knight also named TALOS.

132
00:18:58,120 --> 00:19:04,000
And this Iron Knight was a grim enforcer companion given to her article,

133
00:19:04,000 --> 00:19:15,300
who was a virtuous hero who travelled around the land trying to bring justice to lawbreakers and the Iron Knight TALOS.

134
00:19:15,300 --> 00:19:27,060
Was intended to help him bring law and order to the countryside, but it soon became a relentless killer robot totally without mercy.

135
00:19:27,060 --> 00:19:30,270
Ultimately, this Iron Knight imposed iron law.

136
00:19:30,270 --> 00:19:39,660
The robot had no compassion, no mercy and no interest in individual circumstances, motives, forgiveness or remorse.

137
00:19:39,660 --> 00:19:47,640
And I think that brings up some interesting questions about eye in the law.

138
00:19:47,640 --> 00:19:52,760
Next slide, please.

139
00:19:52,760 --> 00:20:03,380
And now I'm returning to the ancient myth of Jason and the Argonauts tell us, was not the only deadly automaton that media had to overcome.

140
00:20:03,380 --> 00:20:09,640
Jason also had to survive the attacks of a pair of fire breathing bronze bulls.

141
00:20:09,640 --> 00:20:19,960
And an unstoppable automaton army, those technical obstacles belong to a powerful king who wanted Jason dead.

142
00:20:19,960 --> 00:20:27,970
And with Madea's help. Jason was able to subdue the terrifying robo bulls and he took them to a plough.

143
00:20:27,970 --> 00:20:36,340
And next, Jason and his men had to fight and defeat the kings sinister army of invincible atomic

144
00:20:36,340 --> 00:20:42,280
automatic warriors that popped out of the ground fully armed and programmed to attack.

145
00:20:42,280 --> 00:20:54,970
Next slide, please. And here we see a mediaeval image of those automaton soldiers emerging from the field,

146
00:20:54,970 --> 00:21:01,000
fully armed, these diabolical soldiers, they couldn't be commanded or ordered.

147
00:21:01,000 --> 00:21:05,650
They couldn't retreat or halt their sort of hard wired to attack.

148
00:21:05,650 --> 00:21:10,960
And the army of androids advance on the nearest enemy, which is Jason and the Argonauts.

149
00:21:10,960 --> 00:21:20,170
And once again, Madea to the rescue. Madea figures out how to take advantage of the encoding that's imprinted in this unnatural army,

150
00:21:20,170 --> 00:21:24,550
just as she exploited the brothers robots weak points.

151
00:21:24,550 --> 00:21:29,320
She hit on a clever way to trigger them to self-destruct.

152
00:21:29,320 --> 00:21:36,670
Well, I just want to point out that if you're facing machines of malice, you want Madea or someone like her on your side.

153
00:21:36,670 --> 00:21:41,440
She really is an ancient version of a brilliant hacker.

154
00:21:41,440 --> 00:21:50,440
And I think these myths show that the Greeks understood that even the most awesome technology has can have weaknesses,

155
00:21:50,440 --> 00:22:01,960
vulnerabilities that can be exploited and that automatons do not always perform as expected by the maker or or those who deploy them.

156
00:22:01,960 --> 00:22:08,800
Tell us in the bronze bowls or just some of the many marvellous automatons that were made for powerful case by her.

157
00:22:08,800 --> 00:22:12,050
That's just as good as the God of invention.

158
00:22:12,050 --> 00:22:20,230
The first is really had an impressive resume of animated androids and self-loathing devices that he made for

159
00:22:20,230 --> 00:22:26,800
the gods and for himself and the other gods and goddesses is interesting because the only God with the job,

160
00:22:26,800 --> 00:22:28,450
he's the only God who sweats you.

161
00:22:28,450 --> 00:22:39,010
He's always pictured hard at work, is using familiar tools, materials and methods that people saw in real workshops and forges on earth.

162
00:22:39,010 --> 00:22:49,690
But as I mentioned, because Vestas was the god of invention and technology and blacksmithing and forges his imaginary creations were marvellous,

163
00:22:49,690 --> 00:22:56,290
far beyond the dreams of any mere mortal craftsperson could achieve.

164
00:22:56,290 --> 00:22:59,740
Next slide, please.

165
00:22:59,740 --> 00:23:09,750
For example, Homer tells us that he made automated gates for the heavens so the gods could drive their chariots back and forth with ease.

166
00:23:09,750 --> 00:23:17,590
Of the first automatic garage door is here. And Festus also built a fleet of self-driving vehicles.

167
00:23:17,590 --> 00:23:26,350
They were three wheeled autonomous carts that delivered nectar and ambrosia to the gods banquets and then returned when they were empty.

168
00:23:26,350 --> 00:23:33,370
The first is constructed a set of self-regulating bellows for his forge.

169
00:23:33,370 --> 00:23:35,830
And according to Homer in the Iliad,

170
00:23:35,830 --> 00:23:43,240
these automated bellows could blast more or less air depending on what was required by his just as he was working.

171
00:23:43,240 --> 00:23:55,870
But I think one of his most amazing inventions, maybe the most amazing invention, was a crew of life sized, lifelike women made of gold.

172
00:23:55,870 --> 00:23:59,890
And these golden maiden served as his personal helpers.

173
00:23:59,890 --> 00:24:06,790
Homer describes them bustling around the festivities workshop, and they were able to anticipate his every need.

174
00:24:06,790 --> 00:24:12,250
And Homer tells us that the golden maidens looked just like real young women.

175
00:24:12,250 --> 00:24:17,890
And these female androids were intelligent. They were endowed with strength and reason.

176
00:24:17,890 --> 00:24:24,580
And I think most astonishing, Homer says they were equipped with all the knowledge of the gods.

177
00:24:24,580 --> 00:24:36,100
So essentially, these lifelike automatons seem to possess what amounts to a mythological version of a all the knowledge of the gods.

178
00:24:36,100 --> 00:24:49,480
And they they have strength and able to reason. The capstone, however, of Festus creations with yet another lifelike replicant like tell us.

179
00:24:49,480 --> 00:24:53,920
This one was designed to interact with humans on Earth.

180
00:24:53,920 --> 00:25:00,550
And this marvel was called Pandora. Next slide, please.

181
00:25:00,550 --> 00:25:00,910
Now,

182
00:25:00,910 --> 00:25:12,250
I want to point out that Pandora in the original myth was not anything like the fairy tale version that most of us have heard of in our childhoods.

183
00:25:12,250 --> 00:25:19,780
Pandora was not an innocent, curious young woman with a tragic case of curiosity,

184
00:25:19,780 --> 00:25:28,780
couldn't resist opening a forbidden box or jar, inadvertently unleashing a swarm of evils on the world.

185
00:25:28,780 --> 00:25:33,160
The original story of Pandora is much darker.

186
00:25:33,160 --> 00:25:42,640
The myth was first written down by Hesiod, about seven hundred B.C., around the same time that that Homer was describing the golden female servants.

187
00:25:42,640 --> 00:25:47,140
And some of the wording that the two authors use is very similar.

188
00:25:47,140 --> 00:25:56,260
Whishes description makes it very clear that Pandora was an artificial young woman made not born.

189
00:25:56,260 --> 00:26:04,420
And in the myth, the king of the gods zus very vengeful and harsh tyrant decides to take revenge

190
00:26:04,420 --> 00:26:10,300
on human beings for accepting the gift of fire that was stolen by Prometheus.

191
00:26:10,300 --> 00:26:19,060
Zeus commands investors to fabricate an evil disguised as beauty in the form of a lovely and seductive young woman.

192
00:26:19,060 --> 00:26:26,320
This is to be a trap for humans, we are told takes malicious glee in this cruel trick.

193
00:26:26,320 --> 00:26:30,130
He's laughing out loud as he gives the instructions to investors,

194
00:26:30,130 --> 00:26:36,730
telling him to give this bewitching young artificial woman the power to move on its own.

195
00:26:36,730 --> 00:26:46,390
Next, he orders the gods and goddesses to come and bestow gifts, capabilities and personality traits on Pandora.

196
00:26:46,390 --> 00:26:51,250
Afine addresses her in fabulous garments of Aphrodite.

197
00:26:51,250 --> 00:26:58,600
The Goddess of love fills Pandora with irresistible sex appeal and Hermes the messenger.

198
00:26:58,600 --> 00:27:03,850
God instils Pandora with a deceitful, shameless nature.

199
00:27:03,850 --> 00:27:12,540
So this deceptive fembot kind of A.I. agent in the shape of a young woman was to be sent,

200
00:27:12,540 --> 00:27:21,850
sent by zoo down to earth, carrying a sealed jar filled with evils to plague mortals forever.

201
00:27:21,850 --> 00:27:30,520
And her only mission on Earth was to open that fateful jar and release eternal misery and suffering on humankind.

202
00:27:30,520 --> 00:27:40,910
Next slide, please. And here we have a painting of Jesus admiring Pandora made to his specifications before sending her to Earth,

203
00:27:40,910 --> 00:27:46,010
and you can see she looks like a statue or a doll.

204
00:27:46,010 --> 00:27:52,100
And I think it's interesting to cast this myth in robotic A.I. terms.

205
00:27:52,100 --> 00:27:58,250
And this is thanks to a philosopher, George Xhaka Dorkus.

206
00:27:58,250 --> 00:28:10,760
He he points out that's the word used for four Zoosk coming up with the intellectual concept of Pandora, uses the word he says as he crafts that idea.

207
00:28:10,760 --> 00:28:15,710
Then Zus commissions as best as to build the basic hardware.

208
00:28:15,710 --> 00:28:23,870
Vestas makes this female replicant lifelike enough to be accepted as a real young woman by humans.

209
00:28:23,870 --> 00:28:34,520
The other gods then supply the operating system by giving Pandora various humanoid functions and properties and businesses design specifications.

210
00:28:34,520 --> 00:28:45,020
Pandora is programmed to open and then close the jar of Eagles and there therefore accomplish her mission on Earth.

211
00:28:45,020 --> 00:28:51,540
Next slide, please. And this is the magnificent Nairobi vaisse,

212
00:28:51,540 --> 00:29:04,320
more than a foot tall that shows just showing off the completed figure of Pandora to all the gods, and I can give you some better details.

213
00:29:04,320 --> 00:29:09,930
Could see the figures a little better in the next slide, please.

214
00:29:09,930 --> 00:29:14,070
And in the top row, you see Tsou seated on his throne on the left there.

215
00:29:14,070 --> 00:29:19,050
And Pandora is in the top row centre facing out, looking at us.

216
00:29:19,050 --> 00:29:22,740
All the gods and goddesses, as you can see, are very active. They're lively.

217
00:29:22,740 --> 00:29:26,460
They're filled with are at this realistic artificial woman.

218
00:29:26,460 --> 00:29:32,910
They're gesturing and talking. And in the next slide, a close up of Pandora.

219
00:29:32,910 --> 00:29:38,970
Next slide, please. In contrast, Pandora standing there stiffly like a statue.

220
00:29:38,970 --> 00:29:50,340
She's gazing out at us with a kind of uncanny smile. And as one art historian says, she looks like a wind up doll about to be activated.

221
00:29:50,340 --> 00:29:56,610
And what's remarkable is that inves paintings of this time faces looking straight out at the viewer.

222
00:29:56,610 --> 00:30:03,390
That's very rare. A full frontal face indicates a kind of mindlessness.

223
00:30:03,390 --> 00:30:11,550
It's appropriate for for dead dead bodies or inanimate things like masks or statues.

224
00:30:11,550 --> 00:30:16,650
And frontal views like this can also suggest a mesmerising gaze.

225
00:30:16,650 --> 00:30:26,310
And I think on this vaisse, both of those effects, a blank mind and a kind of compelling gaze seem to be intended by the artist.

226
00:30:26,310 --> 00:30:34,690
And the other remarkable thing is facial expressions are also extremely rare in face painting.

227
00:30:34,690 --> 00:30:41,920
But this Pandora is smiling. Does that stature like appearance, that creepy smile?

228
00:30:41,920 --> 00:30:47,340
They represent Pandora as a kind of wicked automaton and that fits.

229
00:30:47,340 --> 00:30:53,670
He sees depiction of Pandora as evil, described as beauty.

230
00:30:53,670 --> 00:30:59,640
And here I have another movie reference. Next slide, please.

231
00:30:59,640 --> 00:31:08,010
Pandora, I think, is eerily reminiscent of the evil robot Maria in the great silent film Metropolis,

232
00:31:08,010 --> 00:31:16,140
which was made in nineteen twenty seven, made just a few years after the invention of the of the word robot.

233
00:31:16,140 --> 00:31:29,100
Next slide, please. Already in Metropolis, that film shows that already by nineteen twenty seven,

234
00:31:29,100 --> 00:31:37,470
people were already imagining a future techno dystopia where the rich ruling class oppressed,

235
00:31:37,470 --> 00:31:50,280
miserable workers with automation and robots in the scene of all of those artificial women being prepared is quite striking.

236
00:31:50,280 --> 00:31:53,910
Well, to return to the Greek myth, next slide, please,

237
00:31:53,910 --> 00:32:04,020
ZUS orders Hermes to escort Pandora to Earth and present her as a bride to a man named Amethyst.

238
00:32:04,020 --> 00:32:13,920
And here we see that. And the guy in the middle there is Hermes finding amusement in the hole in the whole interchange.

239
00:32:13,920 --> 00:32:24,900
Prometheus, humanity's protector, tries to warn Prometheus not to accept this nefarious gift from Snook's.

240
00:32:24,900 --> 00:32:32,880
But Prometheus ignores the warning. He's dazzled by Pandoras beauty, and he, according to Hesiod,

241
00:32:32,880 --> 00:32:41,460
accepts the gift from Zeus and only realises his terrible error to light after he's opened the jar.

242
00:32:41,460 --> 00:32:48,390
And the names here are significant. In ancient Greek, Prometheus means foresight.

243
00:32:48,390 --> 00:32:57,030
Looking ahead at Prometheus means hindsight, and that makes him the perfect patsy for those cruel trap.

244
00:32:57,030 --> 00:33:07,560
And I guess we could draw a lesson here. I think maybe as the science of robotics and A.I. advances at a relentless rate,

245
00:33:07,560 --> 00:33:19,110
maybe we need a few more Promethean thinkers and not just a million people going for short term gains without looking ahead.

246
00:33:19,110 --> 00:33:27,810
And also notice that have Restasis selectwoman devices and automatons are charming, they're harmless.

247
00:33:27,810 --> 00:33:34,830
They're benevolent when they're confined to the heavenly realm, when they're used by the gods and goddesses up in heaven.

248
00:33:34,830 --> 00:33:40,980
But when you sends automatons to earth, things go badly for humans.

249
00:33:40,980 --> 00:33:51,660
You could say that as Isaac Asimov's laws get broken when they come to Earth and the myths seem to be suggesting,

250
00:33:51,660 --> 00:33:58,020
or we can take this lesson that maybe these things are good to think about in the abstract,

251
00:33:58,020 --> 00:34:02,970
but you have to take great care when they interact on a human plate.

252
00:34:02,970 --> 00:34:10,050
I think another point to ponder is the association between technology and tyranny.

253
00:34:10,050 --> 00:34:19,350
It's arousing a lot of concern today and we can notice who commissions and deploys automatons in these myths.

254
00:34:19,350 --> 00:34:26,940
It's people with powers, the gods, especially the tyrannical guards, Zoosk and powerful kings.

255
00:34:26,940 --> 00:34:34,200
And technology then was linked with tyranny very early in human history in these myths.

256
00:34:34,200 --> 00:34:39,600
But this pattern also occurred in real historical times in antiquity,

257
00:34:39,600 --> 00:34:53,740
with examples going back to at least the 6th century B.C. with powerful kings commissioning machines to kill and torture others.

258
00:34:53,740 --> 00:35:01,010
I think Prometheus is a valuable model for those to.

259
00:35:01,010 --> 00:35:11,230
We're thinking about or seeking to create artificial life because he is the one who's always looking out for humankind,

260
00:35:11,230 --> 00:35:17,760
according to Miss, it was Prometheus who made the first human being.

261
00:35:17,760 --> 00:35:29,130
And there is an amazing set of engravings, more than 60 of those engravings on tiny gems worn as rings are made and seals that depict

262
00:35:29,130 --> 00:35:36,450
Prometheus as a kind of engineer using tools to construct the first human prototype.

263
00:35:36,450 --> 00:35:47,850
Next slide, please. He's working step by step, working from the inside out, beginning with the internal framework, the skeleton.

264
00:35:47,850 --> 00:35:53,920
And then he will add muscles and tendons, internal organs and flesh.

265
00:35:53,920 --> 00:36:01,170
And these gems are from about 300 to one hundred B.C. after he made humans.

266
00:36:01,170 --> 00:36:07,110
And we hear this from Sapho very early, early in Greek literature.

267
00:36:07,110 --> 00:36:13,200
Sakwa says that it's that he stole the technology of fire after he made the

268
00:36:13,200 --> 00:36:18,870
first human beings and he stole the fire because he was worried about the naked,

269
00:36:18,870 --> 00:36:23,790
vulnerable humans surviving in the harsh world.

270
00:36:23,790 --> 00:36:30,540
So he stole the technology of fire and taught the first men and women crafts and how to use them,

271
00:36:30,540 --> 00:36:41,340
which allowed them to begin to invent language and plan cooperatively together all sorts of hallmarks of civilisation and culture.

272
00:36:41,340 --> 00:36:52,440
And as I'm sure many of you recall, Mary Shelley's great science fiction novel of 200 years ago, 18 Frankenstein.

273
00:36:52,440 --> 00:37:03,000
It was subtitled A Modern Prometheus and comparing the Prometheus of a Greek myth with the modern scientist in that novel,

274
00:37:03,000 --> 00:37:12,170
Victor Frankenstein, one is struck with the question of what creators might.

275
00:37:12,170 --> 00:37:21,320
Oh, to their creations of artificial mud and Victor Frankenstein, you recall, was repulsed by his creation.

276
00:37:21,320 --> 00:37:24,660
It was monstrous and he disowned it in the end.

277
00:37:24,660 --> 00:37:35,480
Well, Prometheus remains a kind of archetype of the responsible creator who tries to help his creations.

278
00:37:35,480 --> 00:37:42,860
Well, I think these examples from literature and art do show that the ability to imagine making

279
00:37:42,860 --> 00:37:50,360
artificial life automatons robots has more ancient roots than most people realise.

280
00:37:50,360 --> 00:37:55,970
We can trace these cultural dreams of technology all the way back to the myths of classical Greece,

281
00:37:55,970 --> 00:37:59,300
first written down between the 8th and 7th century B.C.

282
00:37:59,300 --> 00:38:05,870
And here I do want to mention that the Greeks were not unique in imagining automatons or artificial life.

283
00:38:05,870 --> 00:38:11,420
Stories about making artificial life also appear in ancient India and China as well.

284
00:38:11,420 --> 00:38:18,590
So it is clear that automatons are not only thinkable long before the technology was available or existed,

285
00:38:18,590 --> 00:38:24,020
but many of the practical and ethical issues about imitating nature.

286
00:38:24,020 --> 00:38:35,330
They're foreshadowed in these ancient myths. If you really look closely at myths about what one could achieve if one had advanced biotechnical.

287
00:38:35,330 --> 00:38:43,850
So just to conclude, it's probably seems ironic to be looking back to the ancient past,

288
00:38:43,850 --> 00:38:51,320
but I've asked you to time travel more than two millennia to consider some of the first science fiction tales.

289
00:38:51,320 --> 00:38:58,490
But I do hope that the sophistication and the relevance of these ancient dreams and the calm's that they

290
00:38:58,490 --> 00:39:08,860
express about technology might enrich our understanding of the timeless link between imagination and science.

291
00:39:08,860 --> 00:39:14,400
Look forward to hearing your comments and questions. Thank you so much, Adrian.

292
00:39:14,400 --> 00:39:18,990
That was a really fascinating presentation and some spectacular images there.

293
00:39:18,990 --> 00:39:29,630
So I want to turn to our first commentator, Professor SandBoxing.

294
00:39:29,630 --> 00:39:37,040
I've enjoyed thinking with Adrienne Mayer's pioneering work on gods and robots in antiquity,

295
00:39:37,040 --> 00:39:45,050
modern A.I. has many manifestations, of course, and Mayer's study leans towards the idea of the robot.

296
00:39:45,050 --> 00:39:54,830
That is the thing made not born, the thing that shares some qualities with human life weathervanes unwilling iCore the ability

297
00:39:54,830 --> 00:40:01,160
for spontaneous movement or the modicum of intelligence needed to serve a glass of wine,

298
00:40:01,160 --> 00:40:05,090
a function which even my dog has not mastered.

299
00:40:05,090 --> 00:40:13,970
Another model for a modern A.I. is that embraced by corporations such as Amazon, Google, Facebook and IBM.

300
00:40:13,970 --> 00:40:26,210
Machine learning systems dedicated to forms of cognition associated with human intelligence such as learning, problem solving and pattern recognition.

301
00:40:26,210 --> 00:40:36,470
Yet another category of A.I. common today includes what we might call human enhancing devices like Data Lassus Wings.

302
00:40:36,470 --> 00:40:46,490
That is, forms of technology that allow us to transcend human abilities while retaining our own humanity, at least for a while.

303
00:40:46,490 --> 00:40:56,900
Mayer's book touches on this last sort of A.I. in passing, but I'd like to expand on her observations in my comments for this panel.

304
00:40:56,900 --> 00:40:57,680
To do so,

305
00:40:57,680 --> 00:41:09,680
I should first point out that most scholars treat ancient Greek techne craft skill as distinct from the modern term technology as Stanley Rosen,

306
00:41:09,680 --> 00:41:12,980
George Grant and Arthur Meltzer have argued.

307
00:41:12,980 --> 00:41:23,150
Technology tries to bend nature to our will, a stance that takes the offensive in seeking to combat or transcend the natural world.

308
00:41:23,150 --> 00:41:32,960
It also brings with it the potential for ruin. Did the ancients think about technology in that sense as well?

309
00:41:32,960 --> 00:41:45,950
I'd suggest that the answer is yes and that we can find and Sophocles the first stirrings of fear about technology over two millennia before our time.

310
00:41:45,950 --> 00:41:56,000
Dr. Mayz robot, Thomas, of course, does not seek to conquer nature except by dint of being a natural and confusing.

311
00:41:56,000 --> 00:42:05,240
The boundary between the animate and the inanimate colours does count in modern terms as a sort of technology.

312
00:42:05,240 --> 00:42:13,550
On the other hand, Tallis fails what we might call the Stanley Rosen test for A.I. He is a wonder,

313
00:42:13,550 --> 00:42:24,160
but he does not have the potential to ruin the world. Data, listen, swings are more complicated, interesting in transcending nature,

314
00:42:24,160 --> 00:42:33,100
they lead to individual death by, but their impact is limited to those who choose to wear them.

315
00:42:33,100 --> 00:42:43,560
It is instead in the famous Danus Ode of Sophocles, Antigoni, I'd suggest that Roslyn's criteria are met.

316
00:42:43,560 --> 00:42:55,350
In that coral oad, the chorus sings, quote, Many things are formidable, danus, none more formidable than men.

317
00:42:55,350 --> 00:43:02,400
He crosses the grey sea beneath the winter wind, passing beneath the surface that surround him.

318
00:43:02,400 --> 00:43:10,410
And he wears away the highest of the gods earth, immortal and wearying as his ploughs go back and forth from year to year,

319
00:43:10,410 --> 00:43:15,840
turning the soil with the aid of the breed of horses, end quote.

320
00:43:15,840 --> 00:43:23,310
According to the chorus, man has also conquered birds and beasts and fish and disease.

321
00:43:23,310 --> 00:43:32,280
Everything besides death skillfull beyond expectation is his techne, the chorus adds.

322
00:43:32,280 --> 00:43:38,940
And so he advances sometimes to evil, at other times to good.

323
00:43:38,940 --> 00:43:48,420
When he applies the laws of the earth and the justice of the courts, he may remain in the city if his aim is gain.

324
00:43:48,420 --> 00:44:05,290
However, he must be out. Techni, as this chorus sees, it strives to overcome the harshness of nature as a whole, it is large scale and offensive.

325
00:44:05,290 --> 00:44:07,870
The chorus is treatment of cleverness,

326
00:44:07,870 --> 00:44:18,970
they note has also corresponds with Aristotle's view in the nick of a key and ethics six 12 that it may be used for good or for evil.

327
00:44:18,970 --> 00:44:29,800
It is the latter when it stops at nothing, when it encompasses all doing pan or and when is that?

328
00:44:29,800 --> 00:44:40,450
The answer lies in the fact that the chorus speaks of the laws of the Earth, not the city and the justice of the gods, not of men.

329
00:44:40,450 --> 00:44:47,110
The Earth and the gods must be the arbitrators of large scale offensive techne.

330
00:44:47,110 --> 00:44:52,750
Even in Sophocles, techne or as Rozin would call it, technology.

331
00:44:52,750 --> 00:45:00,640
The Earth and the gods represent the needs of our planet and an ethical system uncorrupted by human desire.

332
00:45:00,640 --> 00:45:06,820
Anyone who violates these ethical ends for profit is a danger.

333
00:45:06,820 --> 00:45:13,780
Is this not a harbinger of modern technology clad in the pelts of techne?

334
00:45:13,780 --> 00:45:23,680
Jack Elul in the Technological Society argues that more efficient techniques will always triumph over lesser ones,

335
00:45:23,680 --> 00:45:29,780
and that man has no control over this iron clad rule.

336
00:45:29,780 --> 00:45:38,630
In other words, that neither human ethics nor the welfare of our planet can stop us, let alone will,

337
00:45:38,630 --> 00:45:48,770
Sophocles Chorus may have hoped that we could avert this by removing the facilitators of technology from human society, but we have not.

338
00:45:48,770 --> 00:45:54,270
And the fears that the chorus voices may have proven all too true.

339
00:45:54,270 --> 00:46:04,290
Here, I think, is the most terrible information in antiquity of what A.I. and technology could bring thousands of years later.

340
00:46:04,290 --> 00:46:12,400
Thank you. Thank you so much.

341
00:46:12,400 --> 00:46:17,510
I will pass on to a second commentator and thank you.

342
00:46:17,510 --> 00:46:26,360
Thank you very much. I enjoyed hearing Adrianne talk about her book, which I think is terrific and Charlie's comments.

343
00:46:26,360 --> 00:46:36,170
Thank you. I just like to make three broad points touched on three issues which relate to the connexion between

344
00:46:36,170 --> 00:46:43,850
the kind of thing we've heard about in the classical world and the world of ancient Greece and modern.

345
00:46:43,850 --> 00:46:50,510
I assure you, he said the kind of thing that Adrianna's was concentrating on,

346
00:46:50,510 --> 00:46:59,690
at least in the talk, was really to do more with with robots and tools and things created.

347
00:46:59,690 --> 00:47:04,430
Whereas, of course, we tend to think of artificial intelligence as much more,

348
00:47:04,430 --> 00:47:19,640
how we can achieve certain kinds of goals through understanding the way people think or the way we can create artificial ways of thinking.

349
00:47:19,640 --> 00:47:28,940
The kinds of things that Turing Test looks into, for example, it does this thing, whether it's a computer or monitor or something,

350
00:47:28,940 --> 00:47:38,630
know make us think this could be the same level as we are on a human level in terms of human intelligence.

351
00:47:38,630 --> 00:47:51,230
So one thing that it made me think was what would have been the equivalent in the ancient world of having access to some kind of intelligence,

352
00:47:51,230 --> 00:47:54,470
particularly predictive intelligence. One thinks about it.

353
00:47:54,470 --> 00:47:57,290
A lot of what science is doing is trying to say, look,

354
00:47:57,290 --> 00:48:03,800
we want to think about how things will be in the future and how that may benefit us individually or collectively.

355
00:48:03,800 --> 00:48:08,720
And of course, the answer in the ancient world is purely supernatural.

356
00:48:08,720 --> 00:48:22,700
It is the access to divine minds such as that of the God Apollo through the the work the operation of of an individual such as the Delphic Oracle,

357
00:48:22,700 --> 00:48:28,520
the young woman who was said to have gone into a trance.

358
00:48:28,520 --> 00:48:37,220
Apollo invested this woman's body and mind, and from her mouth came intelligence.

359
00:48:37,220 --> 00:48:42,050
People believed instinct deeply in the Delphic oracle.

360
00:48:42,050 --> 00:48:45,530
They would go and ask questions of it.

361
00:48:45,530 --> 00:48:53,750
And what the Oracle said was taken very seriously, though, of course, famously the Delphic oracle was ambiguous.

362
00:48:53,750 --> 00:49:02,720
So what it said could be interpreted, but was likely to be misinterpreted according to the wishful thinking of the recipient.

363
00:49:02,720 --> 00:49:13,950
So that's just one aspect of the idea that artificial intelligence is seeking some kind of.

364
00:49:13,950 --> 00:49:27,870
Some kind of access to knowledge, but that that access may well deceive us through our own projection of what we want onto that thing.

365
00:49:27,870 --> 00:49:40,400
So the second point I just want to take up is what Charlie was saying about the dangers of techno technology being both potentially good and bad and.

366
00:49:40,400 --> 00:49:47,240
One of the things that I looked into for many years and ended up in my book,

367
00:49:47,240 --> 00:49:55,370
The Greece and the New in 2011, was how the Greeks thought about novelty and innovation.

368
00:49:55,370 --> 00:50:02,360
And the standard trope in ancient studies was the Greeks didn't like anything new.

369
00:50:02,360 --> 00:50:07,940
There's a whole book devoted to that in the 1950s, calls in the grip of the past.

370
00:50:07,940 --> 00:50:12,560
And that is the bottom line. The Greeks didn't like anything new.

371
00:50:12,560 --> 00:50:22,700
And this is about a culture which invented philosophy, theatre, the first monetary economy, logic, mathematical proof.

372
00:50:22,700 --> 00:50:33,770
You know, you could go on. How is it that these people, despite not wanting, not liking anything new, managed to be so massively innovative?

373
00:50:33,770 --> 00:50:36,860
I mean, they really were masochists, weren't they?

374
00:50:36,860 --> 00:50:44,390
So one of the things that my book sought to do is show that there were areas in which they not only sought the new,

375
00:50:44,390 --> 00:50:54,530
but they promoted it as a good thing. And when one looks into the history of ancient thinkers talking about innovation,

376
00:50:54,530 --> 00:51:01,800
it's actually hard to find any treatise that talks about the new as such.

377
00:51:01,800 --> 00:51:12,360
About the closest we come to it is Aristotle's Politics, in which he talks about innovative constitutions,

378
00:51:12,360 --> 00:51:22,710
ways in which people came up with imaginative ideas about how to create a new kind of governmental constitution.

379
00:51:22,710 --> 00:51:29,910
And of course, Plato's Republic is one of those. It's a utopia and Aristotle criticises it.

380
00:51:29,910 --> 00:51:36,030
He also talks about some of the communistic schemes that were suggested as national failures of Chalcedon.

381
00:51:36,030 --> 00:51:40,170
He talks about you came up with the idea of sharing property in common.

382
00:51:40,170 --> 00:51:42,570
I an extraordinary proto communism.

383
00:51:42,570 --> 00:51:50,430
And Aristotle comes up with a very good, sensible objections to why it's not going to work, basically because of human nature.

384
00:51:50,430 --> 00:51:56,760
And he talks about Mancos. Hippiedom, amongst other things, was a very great city planner.

385
00:51:56,760 --> 00:52:04,350
And he worked out the grid system that was used in Paris. And he said he was very flamboyant and innovative individual.

386
00:52:04,350 --> 00:52:12,510
Amongst other things. He suggested that there should be a prise instituted for innovative political ideas.

387
00:52:12,510 --> 00:52:17,280
So a prise for coming up with a good new kind of constitution.

388
00:52:17,280 --> 00:52:25,260
So the idea of a prise, of course, leads us to the sort of incentives the Greeks were very keen on rewards and prises.

389
00:52:25,260 --> 00:52:31,590
I mean, they were very competitive and they thought, you know, it is a good prise and you can incentivise things.

390
00:52:31,590 --> 00:52:41,010
Then people will come up with new ideas. So I think that that's an area of Greek society which showed how keen they were on innovation.

391
00:52:41,010 --> 00:52:48,250
And of course, we can talk about a lot of the actual technological innovations that happen at a slightly later period.

392
00:52:48,250 --> 00:52:57,330
Hellenistic another period essentially to do with hydraulics and steam combustion and so on, which was the principle on which our Chitose dive flew.

393
00:52:57,330 --> 00:53:04,680
In fact, it was a kind of steam powered dive. Those things never quite got off the ground.

394
00:53:04,680 --> 00:53:09,150
I once gave a talk on ancient aeronautics, a bit of a tongue in cheek, and I said, you know,

395
00:53:09,150 --> 00:53:15,060
flying was of great interest to the ancient Greeks, but it never quite goes off the ground.

396
00:53:15,060 --> 00:53:20,220
Nonetheless, as I said at the time, flying was in the air and in the 5th century B.C.,

397
00:53:20,220 --> 00:53:23,400
I mean, there was a lot of interest in this idea of using wings.

398
00:53:23,400 --> 00:53:30,810
There's a place called the comedy called The Birds by Aristophanes where people don't wings and pretend to be birds.

399
00:53:30,810 --> 00:53:35,460
And you can imagine people trying out flying in that way.

400
00:53:35,460 --> 00:53:38,730
But what is interesting is a lot of that goes back to Delice,

401
00:53:38,730 --> 00:53:47,190
as we heard from Shaddai and of the invention of a man powered flight by this inventive man,

402
00:53:47,190 --> 00:53:49,830
inventor of all kinds of ways he was supposed to have been.

403
00:53:49,830 --> 00:53:55,020
One of them was that he he built the wings for his son, Icarus, and, of course, failed tremendously.

404
00:53:55,020 --> 00:54:06,960
But where does that very early myth come from? It seems to be connected to the Greeks Connexions, to ancient Egyptians sailing technology.

405
00:54:06,960 --> 00:54:11,190
And if you think about it, when people first come across certain kinds of technology,

406
00:54:11,190 --> 00:54:15,810
they think, my goodness, maybe that means, you know, what are these boats doing?

407
00:54:15,810 --> 00:54:21,450
They actually capturing the wind in sales and flying across the sea.

408
00:54:21,450 --> 00:54:28,040
So maybe we can adapt that kind of technology and think about using it for flying.

409
00:54:28,040 --> 00:54:41,840
So. The idea of techno then as something that might be good or bad, most of the ancients in any text that you read thought that any kind of.

410
00:54:41,840 --> 00:54:47,570
Attempts to scale the sea was a bad thing, sailing was basically seen as negative.

411
00:54:47,570 --> 00:54:53,930
I mean, it was very dangerous. There were frequent shipwrecks there all over the Mediterranean, boats at the bottom of the Mediterranean.

412
00:54:53,930 --> 00:54:59,300
So sailing itself was bad enough. Flying would go one step further.

413
00:54:59,300 --> 00:55:10,670
And, of course, the whole myth of Icarus is dressed up in this idea that he's committing a hubris by attempting to fly too close to the sun,

414
00:55:10,670 --> 00:55:18,770
look at it and fly. His wax wings melt and he falls and becomes the name of the Icarian sea.

415
00:55:18,770 --> 00:55:26,390
And so the third point I want to bring up is the idea of an orientation towards the future, because that,

416
00:55:26,390 --> 00:55:34,550
it seems to me, is something that changes in the history of the physical world as we know it.

417
00:55:34,550 --> 00:55:46,310
One very simple concrete example of this is that when we read in Homer about the Prophet CalCars, we're told he could see behind him.

418
00:55:46,310 --> 00:55:50,030
He could not only see in front of him, he could see behind him.

419
00:55:50,030 --> 00:55:57,830
And what that means is he could not only see the past, which was in front of him, there it is spread out in front of us.

420
00:55:57,830 --> 00:56:04,250
I mean, that was what Karkus could see, but he can see behind, which was the future.

421
00:56:04,250 --> 00:56:11,270
And so one has to imagine that the idea, the imagination of the Greeks at that age with something like this,

422
00:56:11,270 --> 00:56:15,920
we're travelling in a cart, travelling backwards into the future.

423
00:56:15,920 --> 00:56:20,540
We can't see what's going to happen behind us. It might hit us suddenly.

424
00:56:20,540 --> 00:56:25,100
We can, of course, look and see what happens in the past because it's right in front of our eyes.

425
00:56:25,100 --> 00:56:31,160
But we really feel quite blind to the future. As I mentioned, as divination, as the idea of prophecy,

426
00:56:31,160 --> 00:56:38,120
you can perhaps glimpse occasionally behind you like CalCars the prophet and see what's coming.

427
00:56:38,120 --> 00:56:42,380
But on the whole, we are blind to the future. We are facing the past.

428
00:56:42,380 --> 00:56:45,680
And then something changes in the middle of the fifth century B.C.,

429
00:56:45,680 --> 00:56:54,270
the sort of period around 440 when Sophocles is writing his antigoni and that OWD talking about the formidable nature of human beings,

430
00:56:54,270 --> 00:57:00,560
they can do basically anything. The only thing they can't do is stop us from dying.

431
00:57:00,560 --> 00:57:06,380
We created medicine. We created our agriculture, we created cities and ideas.

432
00:57:06,380 --> 00:57:11,900
And it's this wonderful celebration of human ability.

433
00:57:11,900 --> 00:57:22,850
And in that century, we find texts where on the whole, the idea of the future is something that we can look forward to.

434
00:57:22,850 --> 00:57:27,020
The idea of progress first emerges in some form during that century.

435
00:57:27,020 --> 00:57:33,110
The idea that, for example, in medicine we can look forward to a future in which one day,

436
00:57:33,110 --> 00:57:39,410
by analysing disease and health, we can eventually attain the whole of medical knowledge.

437
00:57:39,410 --> 00:57:44,990
They actually say that in some of the Hippocratic treatises as so ambitious, they realise that we can actually do it.

438
00:57:44,990 --> 00:57:51,800
Human beings are now striding forward confidently into a future which is ours.

439
00:57:51,800 --> 00:57:55,160
And of course, there are dangers with that view as well,

440
00:57:55,160 --> 00:58:01,760
because in some ways it is a much more realistic point of view to suggest we simply are travelling backwards,

441
00:58:01,760 --> 00:58:04,490
our faces are oriented towards the front.

442
00:58:04,490 --> 00:58:12,740
And so this image of us as travelling forwards in the future is potentially very dangerous because actually we are not looking at the future.

443
00:58:12,740 --> 00:58:17,660
We are imagining the future and we are imagining the future based on the past.

444
00:58:17,660 --> 00:58:22,100
And so I think this comes very nicely back to what Adrian has said,

445
00:58:22,100 --> 00:58:32,030
because she has managed to increase our sense of the imaginative resources that the ancient Greeks brought to the idea of artificial imagination.

446
00:58:32,030 --> 00:58:37,670
Thank you. Thank you so much. And that's an excellent discussion so far.

447
00:58:37,670 --> 00:58:46,610
Let me ask Adrian, is there anything you'd like to pick up, Adrian, and what's been said before we go to questions?

448
00:58:46,610 --> 00:58:56,330
You need 12 metre. Yes, I really enjoyed those comments, all very astute,

449
00:58:56,330 --> 00:59:02,660
especially enjoy the reference to Sophocles paean to human ingenuity and and

450
00:59:02,660 --> 00:59:10,010
how it could either be used for good or evil and that tendency to imitate,

451
00:59:10,010 --> 00:59:14,240
improve and surpass nature.

452
00:59:14,240 --> 00:59:25,610
And as I think Shotty pointed out, that that is there a feeling of danger to buy automatons or technology?

453
00:59:25,610 --> 00:59:31,040
Is there a danger to more than just individuals and sort of a mass danger?

454
00:59:31,040 --> 00:59:41,050
And I think Armand mentions this, too, about technology.

455
00:59:41,050 --> 00:59:52,700
And competition and rewards and prises, and so if you look at what did the Greeks use technology for practical technology for,

456
00:59:52,700 --> 00:59:57,340
it's for theatre and religions and war.

457
00:59:57,340 --> 01:00:07,840
And no one has mentioned war machines yet, but not all machines of war were rewarded by powerful kings and rulers,

458
01:00:07,840 --> 01:00:21,760
starting with maybe Dionysius of Syracuse in four hundred invited inventors and artisans and engineers to a contest to make advanced weapons of war.

459
01:00:21,760 --> 01:00:31,960
And the competitions spurred them. And this resulted in the first TORSHIN catapult, even the first mechanised catapult.

460
01:00:31,960 --> 01:00:37,510
And now we're taking these prises and contests continue.

461
01:00:37,510 --> 01:00:43,960
Philip of Macedon also rewarded military engineers.

462
01:00:43,960 --> 01:00:56,950
So did Demetrius. Oligarchy's siege these machines and Mr. Davies, the Great, also had many engineers who built innovative war machines in his court.

463
01:00:56,950 --> 01:01:05,440
So and then, of course, Archimedes, who also built a lot of technological machines for war.

464
01:01:05,440 --> 01:01:15,430
So there we see that what you predicted Armaan of competition and the idea that there will be prises for innovation.

465
01:01:15,430 --> 01:01:28,570
It's all right there in in war technology. So so we military engineers invented in order to beat the military industrial complex of the ancient world.

466
01:01:28,570 --> 01:01:37,900
There we there we go. And I as I pointed out in my book, DARPA, the military scientists of the Pentagon,

467
01:01:37,900 --> 01:01:48,790
we're building a an advanced exoskeleton that would be human enhancements and I and make soldiers invulnerable.

468
01:01:48,790 --> 01:01:55,870
And what did they name it? They chose an acronym T a. S Tactical attack.

469
01:01:55,870 --> 01:02:03,530
I can't remember what the acronym was, but they knew the story of TALOS and they wanted to make their soldiers invulnerable like Telo.

470
01:02:03,530 --> 01:02:15,610
So one of the things sometimes is why the Greeks didn't go on and invent the kind of technological advances that we we see ourselves.

471
01:02:15,610 --> 01:02:19,930
I think there's every reason that they could have done had it not been that they were concentrating

472
01:02:19,930 --> 01:02:27,550
on military technology and conquest because they invented hydraulics and steam machines.

473
01:02:27,550 --> 01:02:29,050
Already in the third century,

474
01:02:29,050 --> 01:02:35,980
we'd have had an industrial revolution had it not been for Alexander's desire and his successors desire to conquer the world and divide it up.

475
01:02:35,980 --> 01:02:44,200
So Demosthenes says, we have reached an age in which we have come to the end of innovation because it's all military.

476
01:02:44,200 --> 01:02:47,880
And I think that must have been the case. Yeah.

477
01:02:47,880 --> 01:02:54,660
Though it is kind of interesting to note that a lot of our contemporary innovations are also driven by military spending,

478
01:02:54,660 --> 01:02:59,310
but I guess in a very broad sort of way. Let me go to a question from our audience.

479
01:02:59,310 --> 01:03:05,580
This is from Liz. She asks, Did the Greeks and Romans think of progress in a linear way?

480
01:03:05,580 --> 01:03:09,660
Did they think society was improving or did they have a different way of viewing?

481
01:03:09,660 --> 01:03:14,580
Time connects up a little bit with comments, comments at the end. Anyone want to take that up?

482
01:03:14,580 --> 01:03:19,800
Maybe go ahead. And before you come, I want our man to comment on it.

483
01:03:19,800 --> 01:03:25,410
But I was struck by your idea of whether the past is in front of us or behind us.

484
01:03:25,410 --> 01:03:33,420
And there are anthropological studies of various cultures that imagine how do they imagine their ancestors?

485
01:03:33,420 --> 01:03:41,640
Did they imagine themselves at the head of the line of the ancestors behind them, or are they marching behind their ancestors?

486
01:03:41,640 --> 01:03:44,010
And there are differences in various cultures.

487
01:03:44,010 --> 01:03:51,990
And as you say, the Greeks had they had the idea that the that they were one way and then began to change.

488
01:03:51,990 --> 01:03:54,930
So now I think you should answer the question.

489
01:03:54,930 --> 01:04:01,380
Well, just in response to that question of famously, the Greeks at the earliest, Greeks believed in regress, not progress.

490
01:04:01,380 --> 01:04:11,820
And he said in the seven eight, the 7th century gives the myth of how human society has simply regressed over various

491
01:04:11,820 --> 01:04:18,450
different ages from a golden age far in the past to a Bronze Age and Iron Age.

492
01:04:18,450 --> 01:04:26,370
And the next stage is going to be even worse. So that's a massive of is quite common in the ancient world.

493
01:04:26,370 --> 01:04:29,800
And you find it all the way through and even into Roman times.

494
01:04:29,800 --> 01:04:39,180
But alongside that and beginning in the fifth century, basically, as exemplified exactly by the antoniades, which Chardy read out,

495
01:04:39,180 --> 01:04:49,560
you have this sense of increasing ability, a growth and capacity of human abilities and knowledge which will lead to a better future.

496
01:04:49,560 --> 01:04:54,990
So famously, Dods wrote a book called The Greek Ideal of Progress as a series of essays in

497
01:04:54,990 --> 01:04:59,400
which he talks about how there is this switch towards an idea of progress.

498
01:04:59,400 --> 01:05:05,460
But it's not our idea of process, which some continuous linear one, which is mentioned by the questioner,

499
01:05:05,460 --> 01:05:11,640
is that in certain areas, in certain ways, we can do better in future and we will.

500
01:05:11,640 --> 01:05:19,090
But I think that that basic idea that things are always getting worse and certainly morally worse is continuously present in the world.

501
01:05:19,090 --> 01:05:28,120
And they also tend to look at past societies as having advanced technology, for instance,

502
01:05:28,120 --> 01:05:33,250
the way they the way the Greeks looked at Egypt and building the pyramids and things like that.

503
01:05:33,250 --> 01:05:37,630
So. So there's this idea that people in the past.

504
01:05:37,630 --> 01:05:45,990
Whether in real history or remote history or myth had advanced technology that that we don't have now.

505
01:05:45,990 --> 01:05:51,690
Tony, you want to talk about the Roman conceptions? It's the same in the Roman world.

506
01:05:51,690 --> 01:05:58,080
This idea of a falling away from a state of of moral purity,

507
01:05:58,080 --> 01:06:06,060
an age in which the earth gave up its goods automatically without man having to toil for them, which seems to be a universal story,

508
01:06:06,060 --> 01:06:07,980
very much reminiscent, for example,

509
01:06:07,980 --> 01:06:17,190
of the Adam and Eve story in which it's only after the fall that Adam has to scramble in the fields and it has to be the pains of childbirth.

510
01:06:17,190 --> 01:06:18,920
So definitely in the real world. Yes.

511
01:06:18,920 --> 01:06:27,850
And one of the propaganda points that Augustus leans on heavily when it comes to power after 31 B.C. is that he's going to reverse the small book.

512
01:06:27,850 --> 01:06:34,440
And one of the things he doesn't see restores all the ancient temples in the city of Rome as part of this new

513
01:06:34,440 --> 01:06:41,640
way of thinking about what who the Romans are and what they're accomplishing during this first Pax Romana.

514
01:06:41,640 --> 01:06:50,040
Can I ask a follow up about this? Because you talked about a shift in the understanding of time and the future is something we can look forward to.

515
01:06:50,040 --> 01:06:58,380
How does that relate to conceptions of hope? So, for example, in the Pandora movies, there's a suspicion that hope is a mug's game,

516
01:06:58,380 --> 01:07:06,570
that basically it's this optimistic attitude you have basically on the basis of ignorance or someone's manipulating you.

517
01:07:06,570 --> 01:07:12,060
Do we then get our personhood becoming something that is closer to see the understanding

518
01:07:12,060 --> 01:07:17,820
of it as a virtue or at least an element of a virtue as this change happens?

519
01:07:17,820 --> 01:07:26,370
Yes, mean I think, again, textually you can find examples. And again, in the Hippocratic Corpus, in some of the treaties, that very word is used.

520
01:07:26,370 --> 01:07:32,430
There is a hope, I say, that we will get the whole knowledge of health and disease.

521
01:07:32,430 --> 01:07:38,310
So that is sometime later this century, probably that treaties before that.

522
01:07:38,310 --> 01:07:45,390
And I didn't with this very nicely in Hesiod, you have this jar of evils.

523
01:07:45,390 --> 01:07:49,620
All the evils come into the world and what is left is hope.

524
01:07:49,620 --> 01:07:55,380
So on the face of it, hope is yet one other evil that is the one that is retained.

525
01:07:55,380 --> 01:08:06,240
So the idea that hope itself is blind, that hope is not something that we really want to have, but we are left with it.

526
01:08:06,240 --> 01:08:11,190
It's a very hard image to interpret.

527
01:08:11,190 --> 01:08:19,320
But the invitation, I think, is that he was yet one of the other evils, because hope is vain.

528
01:08:19,320 --> 01:08:27,900
Hope is not knowledge, and that is what's left. And I think that can also be traced as something that changes hope,

529
01:08:27,900 --> 01:08:35,580
as bad expectation turning into hope as a good expectation over the course of a few centuries.

530
01:08:35,580 --> 01:08:38,550
If I could add a little footnote to that,

531
01:08:38,550 --> 01:08:47,760
Armande mentioned the pronouncements of the Oracle of Apollo as being as a way of imagining the future in antiquity.

532
01:08:47,760 --> 01:08:54,720
And I just wanted to point out that every single literary representation we have of of those oracles being

533
01:08:54,720 --> 01:09:02,460
uttered show us that they are misinterpreted through the hope of the person receiving the pronouncement.

534
01:09:02,460 --> 01:09:10,740
So, for example, I think it's Christmas or somebody else hears from the Oracle, you will destroy a great empire and all he wishes with his army,

535
01:09:10,740 --> 01:09:15,900
assuming that the empire he destroys will not be his own, which of course, it is.

536
01:09:15,900 --> 01:09:21,840
So hope is very destructive in that context. Brilliant if you ask a really silly question.

537
01:09:21,840 --> 01:09:27,030
But you depicted Prometheus building a human.

538
01:09:27,030 --> 01:09:31,780
So how is the human brain different from Pandora, who's also.

539
01:09:31,780 --> 01:09:39,640
And there we have the philosophical question that is still being pondered, I mean, if you think of the Gnostics,

540
01:09:39,640 --> 01:09:49,090
for instance, they they believe that we were all a product of incompetent Demi urges.

541
01:09:49,090 --> 01:09:55,420
And Plato actually is the one of the first to express that that question.

542
01:09:55,420 --> 01:10:03,280
He he says let's let's imagine or let's pretend or let's consider that we are all puppets of the gods.

543
01:10:03,280 --> 01:10:09,880
So it certainly brings up all sorts of questions of autonomy and free will.

544
01:10:09,880 --> 01:10:19,360
If he's if we are but a technological project of Prometheus, how do we have free will?

545
01:10:19,360 --> 01:10:24,730
It goes on and on. I mean, that that question is still pondered, of course.

546
01:10:24,730 --> 01:10:32,770
Let me ask you this question from Stan Gilmore. He says, Pandora, who is a robot and it seems rather foolish.

547
01:10:32,770 --> 01:10:38,740
First to Pyra, mother of Helen father agrees by Deucalion.

548
01:10:38,740 --> 01:10:44,110
So I stopped humanity from dying out and brought forth the grand civilisation.

549
01:10:44,110 --> 01:10:49,850
Do we owe it all to EHI? That's a very Brigg's a very complex,

550
01:10:49,850 --> 01:11:03,060
interesting questions about whether or not artificial life can reproduce itself, whether replicants like Pandora.

551
01:11:03,060 --> 01:11:07,800
Or Galatea in the Pygmalion story, can could they reproduce,

552
01:11:07,800 --> 01:11:18,510
we never hear anything about Pandora after she has opened the jar, completed her mission on Earth in Greek literature.

553
01:11:18,510 --> 01:11:23,160
The story that that she actually married Eva.

554
01:11:23,160 --> 01:11:23,490
Yes.

555
01:11:23,490 --> 01:11:34,710
And reproduced had offspring, I believe comes from the Roman writer who could not resist saying that she was so lifelike that she could have babies.

556
01:11:34,710 --> 01:11:40,200
And that's where the story comes, comes from that she did reproduce.

557
01:11:40,200 --> 01:11:50,070
And I think it's her genus. And even later, Roman writer who says that Pygmalion and Galatea also had children.

558
01:11:50,070 --> 01:11:58,140
So I think that's just a science fiction tendency that people just couldn't resist thinking about.

559
01:11:58,140 --> 01:12:02,160
And it's, of course, the theme of Blade Runner.

560
01:12:02,160 --> 01:12:15,630
Forty nine, the most recent Blade Runner film is turns on the mystery of the question of whether or not a replicant woman could actually give birth.

561
01:12:15,630 --> 01:12:24,060
So I just think that's a probably a bit of this should say that, of course, the first man has to be made out of clay,

562
01:12:24,060 --> 01:12:29,370
whether it's in the Greek tradition or in the Hebrew tradition, the biblical tradition.

563
01:12:29,370 --> 01:12:39,360
Adam, he's earth. And there is this misogynistic element in common to ancient societies whereby women as secondary.

564
01:12:39,360 --> 01:12:49,290
You, Eve, is made out of Adam's rib. Pandora comes along to destroy the sort of wonderful life that men are having.

565
01:12:49,290 --> 01:12:57,750
So I think one has to accept that there are certain cultural, culturally specific ways of thinking about both men and women,

566
01:12:57,750 --> 01:13:04,980
but nonetheless that initially there has to be animal from inanimate animals.

567
01:13:04,980 --> 01:13:08,650
Breathe into clay after that.

568
01:13:08,650 --> 01:13:13,590
Yeah, you have human reproduction. Apart from individual creations.

569
01:13:13,590 --> 01:13:19,950
There is another story about justice making various robotic guard dogs for

570
01:13:19,950 --> 01:13:27,990
various kings to guard their palaces and a later Roman writer than it might be.

571
01:13:27,990 --> 01:13:37,860
Jenice claims that Melosi and the best melosi and hounds actually there,

572
01:13:37,860 --> 01:13:45,030
they were descendants of the robotic dogs of gold and silver that were made by happenstance.

573
01:13:45,030 --> 01:13:51,420
So once again, you just it's just a natural science fiction type of idea.

574
01:13:51,420 --> 01:14:00,690
It's an interesting there's an interesting many, many cultures have the idea that the first humans were made from mud or clay,

575
01:14:00,690 --> 01:14:06,390
soil and water or tears or blood or something like that.

576
01:14:06,390 --> 01:14:13,320
But it's rare that they have any technology or technique associated with them.

577
01:14:13,320 --> 01:14:21,360
The biblical story doesn't really have a craft associated with the creation,

578
01:14:21,360 --> 01:14:27,660
whereas the images of Prometheus do show him using tools and it's technological.

579
01:14:27,660 --> 01:14:38,370
The only other ancient story I know that's similar to the Prometheus type of story is the Egyptian myth of cartoon,

580
01:14:38,370 --> 01:14:45,300
and I'm not pronouncing it correctly. Who was the God who made the first humans?

581
01:14:45,300 --> 01:14:54,150
And he is the God of the Potter's Wheel, which is technology that was perfected in Egypt about about three thousand.

582
01:14:54,150 --> 01:15:03,000
And he is shown creating the first humans on a potter's wheel, which involves technology plus the clay and the earth and water.

583
01:15:03,000 --> 01:15:11,070
So I think that's a really interesting difference in in those ancient stories of the first humans.

584
01:15:11,070 --> 01:15:19,170
Can I ask a question about a trip that came up that is very popular, which is that of robots or Aiyaz Mercilus,

585
01:15:19,170 --> 01:15:24,010
so we had a discussion recently in the institute about autonomous weapons systems.

586
01:15:24,010 --> 01:15:34,950
One of the objections to deploying them in war is that unlike a human soldier, they wouldn't show mercy towards other combatants or non-combatants.

587
01:15:34,950 --> 01:15:44,610
So the question is, why is there this association or in the Greek context between mercilessness and being an automaton?

588
01:15:44,610 --> 01:15:49,260
Now, it's probably important to distinguish two ideas. One is the idea of equity.

589
01:15:49,260 --> 01:15:54,270
So the idea that you have a rule, but in a particular case, this rule doesn't apply.

590
01:15:54,270 --> 01:15:59,850
So you need the flexibility to realise that a rule shouldn't be applied rigidly in this case.

591
01:15:59,850 --> 01:16:06,270
So that's one idea that this kind of flexibility in the application of rules, knowing when to deviate.

592
01:16:06,270 --> 01:16:12,810
But the other is the more I guess probably more, Román, in my view, kind of idea and sinica,

593
01:16:12,810 --> 01:16:20,070
that sometimes something is just a punishment is justly deserved, but nonetheless out of mercy here.

594
01:16:20,070 --> 01:16:23,250
You might then moderate justice, a punishment.

595
01:16:23,250 --> 01:16:38,110
Why is there a link between mercilessness of either of these sorts and being an automaton in this great context?

596
01:16:38,110 --> 01:16:44,210
You're right, the robots, one of these robots lacking, in other words, that makes the Mercilus.

597
01:16:44,210 --> 01:16:58,640
Well, they're half human and half machine or partly partly more cyborg like and their humanity part seems to be about themselves rather than others,

598
01:16:58,640 --> 01:17:05,450
at least in the tell a story. He makes a bad decision based on what he wants.

599
01:17:05,450 --> 01:17:10,850
But what you're talking about, the drones and killing from afar,

600
01:17:10,850 --> 01:17:21,530
which caused a lot of ambiguous feelings in in antiquity in Greece, the ambivalent feelings about archers,

601
01:17:21,530 --> 01:17:33,620
for instance, who can kill from afar without facing battle face to face now that its its brains are over brawn and still have celebrated, of course.

602
01:17:33,620 --> 01:17:48,910
But there's also this feeling that ambush and arrows or the technology of being able to kill from afar is somehow in vain because it's.

603
01:17:48,910 --> 01:17:54,370
It violates the principle of reciprocal risk in face to face fighting,

604
01:17:54,370 --> 01:18:03,400
you have reciprocal risk and with the drones and those kinds of modern weapons, we certainly don't have reciprocal reviews.

605
01:18:03,400 --> 01:18:11,260
And we know that the army, at least in the Gulf wars of the early Gulf War, nineteen ninety one thousand three,

606
01:18:11,260 --> 01:18:19,240
looked for soldiers who were really good at first person video games where they were.

607
01:18:19,240 --> 01:18:24,240
You cannot have any mercy. You can't stop to think who you're killing.

608
01:18:24,240 --> 01:18:29,810
They looked for soldiers who were adept at that and had practised.

609
01:18:29,810 --> 01:18:33,610
Getting rid of empathy for people that are killing.

610
01:18:33,610 --> 01:18:41,890
I could just add something, which is that, of course, not all the robotic creatures such as those aliens talking about are maligned.

611
01:18:41,890 --> 01:18:48,250
So the golden assistance officers are things that we'd all like to have in the house, really.

612
01:18:48,250 --> 01:18:56,560
But it seems to me that this is where another nation comes in, and that is the notion of the uncanny.

613
01:18:56,560 --> 01:19:03,940
And a lot of I mean, Freud talked about the untimely here, which is the notion of the uncanny.

614
01:19:03,940 --> 01:19:11,770
It's related to the double the doppelganger. And the reason that a doppelganger is uncanny is because it is so like us.

615
01:19:11,770 --> 01:19:20,950
So we might see a square object which is emitting fire as as threatening, but not uncanny and horrible,

616
01:19:20,950 --> 01:19:27,670
but something that looks like a human being, something that is crazy human but isn't actually human is much worse.

617
01:19:27,670 --> 01:19:33,760
And you think of Planet of the Apes or you think actually even of Daleks, I mean, God has scared me.

618
01:19:33,760 --> 01:19:36,790
Of those, the 1980s. They aren't really even human looking.

619
01:19:36,790 --> 01:19:44,020
But because they kind of talk and they move in a slightly uncannily human way, know, that is,

620
01:19:44,020 --> 01:19:52,630
I think, what's going on, especially with these very lifelike robot characters like TALOS.

621
01:19:52,630 --> 01:20:03,130
Recently, a Boston Dynamics just released a video of some of their incredibly advanced robots dancing,

622
01:20:03,130 --> 01:20:12,520
and they they they actually presented this as, see, robots are less intimidating because they can dance.

623
01:20:12,520 --> 01:20:17,050
And I believe that many of us here are saying, no, no,

624
01:20:17,050 --> 01:20:23,440
we're here because all the I felt bad for all the graduate students in dance mechanics

625
01:20:23,440 --> 01:20:28,840
and things like that body movement who were helping Boston mechanics make these moves.

626
01:20:28,840 --> 01:20:42,770
These moves are for killer robots and. But this happens a lot, people who are making advanced technology presented to us as beneficial.

627
01:20:42,770 --> 01:20:48,140
For instance, we have libris, cameras, this will be such a boon to you.

628
01:20:48,140 --> 01:20:54,240
And we but we all know all the dark reasons that they're making, so.

629
01:20:54,240 --> 01:20:57,950
We need to be Promethea.

630
01:20:57,950 --> 01:21:07,130
Let me ask one final question, and that is that might be thought that through all the fears that technological advance and A.I. conjures up,

631
01:21:07,130 --> 01:21:10,860
the Greeks were immune to one of the fears that we have.

632
01:21:10,860 --> 01:21:16,710
Because a lot of people, when they think about the problems with I worry about the future of work and they say,

633
01:21:16,710 --> 01:21:22,710
well, obviously work is a way of making a livelihood. So there is a financial or economic aspect to it.

634
01:21:22,710 --> 01:21:29,040
But it's also a source of self-respect and self-fulfilment that for a lot of people,

635
01:21:29,040 --> 01:21:38,160
doing work is what gives meaning to their lives and that they fear because even if there was a universal basic income,

636
01:21:38,160 --> 01:21:45,240
they would lose this source of meaning. I take it the Greeks did have this anxiety.

637
01:21:45,240 --> 01:21:52,380
They didn't value work in this way. Well, what would be considered more menial, at least in ancient Athens,

638
01:21:52,380 --> 01:21:59,460
where it was relegated to non-citizens and slaves and the the definition of

639
01:21:59,460 --> 01:22:05,760
the human was the man who participated in the life of the city and politics,

640
01:22:05,760 --> 01:22:09,930
which is what Greek citizen males of Athens did do.

641
01:22:09,930 --> 01:22:17,940
And so they simply found their meaning in a different realm. They had other people doing the hard work, the hard labour of of farming or mining.

642
01:22:17,940 --> 01:22:23,130
They reap the benefits themselves and they could spend all their lives yakking it up.

643
01:22:23,130 --> 01:22:28,190
And they said, that's great, because John Maynard Keynes raises this question.

644
01:22:28,190 --> 01:22:33,450
He says, you know, one of the few justifications for having the super rich is that they are pioneering

645
01:22:33,450 --> 01:22:38,760
for us what it would be like to have a meaningful life if you didn't have to work,

646
01:22:38,760 --> 01:22:44,190
if you weren't constrained by necessity. So do the Greeks have an answer to that anxiety yukking it up?

647
01:22:44,190 --> 01:22:49,620
Is that the answer? Look at the Garden of Eden.

648
01:22:49,620 --> 01:22:54,930
Look at the God of innovation first, as he's always shown working.

649
01:22:54,930 --> 01:23:00,660
He's described as perspiring in his work. He doesn't have to do that.

650
01:23:00,660 --> 01:23:05,490
He's a God. On the other hand, he's a disabled God.

651
01:23:05,490 --> 01:23:12,600
So you can imagine that maybe that's why he builds all these practical aids.

652
01:23:12,600 --> 01:23:18,330
But we do have we do have an example of all these gods and goddesses have lives of pleasure to

653
01:23:18,330 --> 01:23:24,480
jack it up and gossip and that they don't necessarily do philosophy like the ancient Greek elites.

654
01:23:24,480 --> 01:23:29,550
Imagine themselves do it. But there is one God who works hard.

655
01:23:29,550 --> 01:23:35,130
Yes. And he is not a model for any ancient Greeks who aspire to that.

656
01:23:35,130 --> 01:23:44,850
More to the point, they didn't even aspire to being, for example, artists as it is a Lucian dialogue in which a young man who said,

657
01:23:44,850 --> 01:23:51,060
well, even if you could be polyglots, the great sculptural fides, you know, you wouldn't want to be that.

658
01:23:51,060 --> 01:24:01,290
So that kind of work was not valued. And I should just remind you that in Aristotle's ethics, when he talks about what makes us you diamine happy,

659
01:24:01,290 --> 01:24:10,110
what makes for well being, what's his answer to eternal contemplation of the truths of mathematics?

660
01:24:10,110 --> 01:24:14,880
What we have to do is find what makes human beings flourishing and happy.

661
01:24:14,880 --> 01:24:23,520
That doesn't involve what we normally call work. Definitely the contemplation of mathematics like I know it.

662
01:24:23,520 --> 01:24:30,750
Thank you very much, everyone. This has been an amazing discussion. Thank you for that wonderful talk and the fantastic graphics.

663
01:24:30,750 --> 01:24:37,060
Thank you to our two excellent commentators, Botch and Dango.

664
01:24:37,060 --> 01:24:45,360
I just want to mention that on February the 16th, we will have a launch event on the democratic culture.

665
01:24:45,360 --> 01:24:57,390
So please join us at 5:00 pm on February the 16th. Speakers will be Professor Josh Cohen, Professor Helen Langmore and Sir Nigel Shadbolt.

666
01:24:57,390 --> 01:25:07,480
So that will be a very interesting discussion about a number of very topical issues related to the interplay between free and democracy.

667
01:25:07,480 --> 01:25:11,430
Thank you again for tuning in and hopefully see you next week.

668
01:25:11,430 --> 01:26:00,072
Thank you, everybody. Thank you.