1
00:00:14,280 --> 00:00:27,330
Welcome everyone to our final and in some ways, climactic event of this three day conference emptiness ways of seeing this final event is,

2
00:00:27,330 --> 00:00:31,350
in some ways a hybrid event for a hybrid conference.

3
00:00:31,350 --> 00:00:40,110
We are having a roundtable where we're going to be discussing certain themes that we've discussed throughout the last few days, and it's also,

4
00:00:40,110 --> 00:00:54,120
in some ways, a kind of pre-launch for a forthcoming book On the Edge Life at the Along the Russia China border by Colleen Humphrey and Frank Miller.

5
00:00:54,120 --> 00:00:58,890
I just wanted to recount quickly what we've been discussing the last three days as a way

6
00:00:58,890 --> 00:01:05,730
of an introduction on the segue we into what Colleen and Frank are going to talk about.

7
00:01:05,730 --> 00:01:10,590
We've heard about depopulated model tones in Latvia,

8
00:01:10,590 --> 00:01:17,190
abandoned industrial settlements and Karelia roads bypassed in Kazakhstan by

9
00:01:17,190 --> 00:01:23,580
the dry dying villages in Eastern Europe and ghost towns in Inner Mongolia,

10
00:01:23,580 --> 00:01:28,920
military townships in Taipei to Albanian bunkers,

11
00:01:28,920 --> 00:01:39,990
tax schemes in post-industrial frontiers to post-Soviet rust belts and how they've been in global value chains.

12
00:01:39,990 --> 00:01:48,000
F emptiness as a consequence of the intersection of state and capital with population and territory than its genesis.

13
00:01:48,000 --> 00:01:59,160
Its presence, in essence, should be most visible at margins and edges, on borders and on the edge.

14
00:01:59,160 --> 00:02:05,760
Humphrey and Frank Buckley assert that despite sharing what Gilbert Roseman calls polite identities,

15
00:02:05,760 --> 00:02:12,500
these two countries are unleashed all the way down onto their very peripheries.

16
00:02:12,500 --> 00:02:17,120
There's no functioning road, a real bridge connecting the two countries across this border,

17
00:02:17,120 --> 00:02:23,690
one in the largest in the world, not withstanding decades of estrangement and hermetic closure forever.

18
00:02:23,690 --> 00:02:32,570
The initiation of tentative contact in the beginning of significant cross-fertilisation provides the context the authors take as their field.

19
00:02:32,570 --> 00:02:40,460
They draw upon a large and current and recent anthropological, sociological, geographical and political perspectives.

20
00:02:40,460 --> 00:02:53,850
Although by and large, the issue theorising and yet on the edge pervades many groundbreaking insights into this truly important global relationship.

21
00:02:53,850 --> 00:03:03,090
And it really makes perfect contributions to themes that we've discussed throughout this conference around about the areas of state capital,

22
00:03:03,090 --> 00:03:14,610
population migration and what we discussed in the first round table with Saskia Sass and Johanna Bookman, Don Kalb and many others.

23
00:03:14,610 --> 00:03:24,900
So let me introduce our distinguished speakers. We have Professor Carlene Humphrey, who's an Emeritus Professor and fellow King's College Cambridge,

24
00:03:24,900 --> 00:03:31,260
the director and the former director and founder of Miyoshi, the Mongolian Innovation Studies Institute.

25
00:03:31,260 --> 00:03:42,990
And over five decades has produced a huge corpus of scholarship about post-Soviet and Soviet Eurasia and from Karl Marx Collective to On the Edge.

26
00:03:42,990 --> 00:03:53,760
She's written many co-authored books, and we have her co-author and a very innovative and theoretically important scholar,

27
00:03:53,760 --> 00:04:02,760
Frank Buckley, who has written his monograph Scene of Obama and published What Women as sovereignties William in his state story.

28
00:04:02,760 --> 00:04:13,740
A very significant work that we've already kind of taken into our and thought within our emptiness project, and he has many other books on the way.

29
00:04:13,740 --> 00:04:20,460
Very productive scholar, and we have three very expert panellists.

30
00:04:20,460 --> 00:04:25,260
We have Madeleine Reeves, who's professor of anthropology at the University of Manchester,

31
00:04:25,260 --> 00:04:33,030
who is a leading scholar of Central Central Asia, borders migration sovereignty.

32
00:04:33,030 --> 00:04:42,720
And that's evidenced in border work, her first monograph and in a recent edited volume, The Everyday Lives of Sovereignty.

33
00:04:42,720 --> 00:04:53,400
We have Alexandru Repac, who is a Afraid Geist fellow at Alemu and associate professor at Tallinn,

34
00:04:53,400 --> 00:05:05,730
who's published Borderland Infrastructure just last year, and many interesting articles from Reconceptualize Izumi to Rewilding.

35
00:05:05,730 --> 00:05:12,510
And finally, we have Natalia Juva, who's a pre-eminent scholar of the Russian Far East,

36
00:05:12,510 --> 00:05:19,080
an economist and an economic anthropologist who's written extensively about Russia,

37
00:05:19,080 --> 00:05:24,330
China border, especially about trade migration, informal economies.

38
00:05:24,330 --> 00:05:32,190
And I can't think of a more qualified audience panel to comment on this new work.

39
00:05:32,190 --> 00:05:39,910
So if Katty and Frank could tell us a little bit about that, then we could hear from our panellists on incidents of discussion.

40
00:05:39,910 --> 00:05:47,580
So over to you. We're very, very grateful to have the opportunity to come and talk to you and thank you for

41
00:05:47,580 --> 00:05:51,780
the three readers who've taken the time to read the book and made comments.

42
00:05:51,780 --> 00:05:57,300
We're really looking forward to hearing what you thought about it and also about your question.

43
00:05:57,300 --> 00:06:01,350
So before we start, I I thought we could.

44
00:06:01,350 --> 00:06:04,710
I could just say a few words about the genesis of the book.

45
00:06:04,710 --> 00:06:17,850
So the book was is based on the project that Caroline and myself and around 20 other people have worked on at Cambridge between 2012 and 2015,

46
00:06:17,850 --> 00:06:23,730
and the project was looking at the interaction between Russia and China.

47
00:06:23,730 --> 00:06:26,010
It was in the context of yes,

48
00:06:26,010 --> 00:06:39,450
I'll see call for projects looking at different arising powers we saw in Russia and China were very interesting on their own terms,

49
00:06:39,450 --> 00:06:42,300
but also because they share a border.

50
00:06:42,300 --> 00:06:50,940
As anthropologists, we would be able to look at what's happening at the border, a daily interaction and better understand what's happening.

51
00:06:50,940 --> 00:07:05,610
We found that rising powers tended to be described and studied at very high level, looking at what's happening at the centre of the capital.

52
00:07:05,610 --> 00:07:12,030
And we wanted to see what was happening on the border, the the daily interaction between between people.

53
00:07:12,030 --> 00:07:21,840
So this was the application for that project was really our first experience of writing together, and we spanned many,

54
00:07:21,840 --> 00:07:31,690
many weeks labouring and Caroline's office at Cambridge, writing and thinking about every sentence.

55
00:07:31,690 --> 00:07:38,700
So it was really a really interesting and really useful way of of preparing for that book,

56
00:07:38,700 --> 00:07:44,070
really, that we didn't know the time that we would write together. So why were we interested in that border?

57
00:07:44,070 --> 00:07:52,290
So as as I said just now it was, it's a unique vantage point to look at interaction between these two.

58
00:07:52,290 --> 00:07:59,430
States, but it's also a very unique border in the sense that it's there is really a hard

59
00:07:59,430 --> 00:08:08,790
fracture between the two because the border was set before the majority groups,

60
00:08:08,790 --> 00:08:15,720
the Russians and Chinese and Han Chinese moved to the region. And because the border was closed for a long time,

61
00:08:15,720 --> 00:08:24,450
we have two very dissimilar cultures or civilisations that even people would describe them on either side.

62
00:08:24,450 --> 00:08:34,620
So it was very interesting for us to see that unique break between these two ways of doing things in other borders,

63
00:08:34,620 --> 00:08:37,050
even difficult borders like the U.S. and Mexico.

64
00:08:37,050 --> 00:08:46,560
There's a lot of intermarriages as along the border was created, was was sent after people were already living there.

65
00:08:46,560 --> 00:08:59,610
So this was really going to be unique. So this book and Kerry will talk a little bit about that as well was a challenge in in two ways.

66
00:08:59,610 --> 00:09:08,730
The first one was that we were writing a a book that would be across academic and trade.

67
00:09:08,730 --> 00:09:14,070
That was a very unique and first experience for us.

68
00:09:14,070 --> 00:09:22,620
The it required some pushback in terms of, you know, sometimes we wanted to go deep into theory and we had to be really mindful of that.

69
00:09:22,620 --> 00:09:27,960
And I remember today that actually when we pitched the book to Harvard, we also had a discussion with Penguin.

70
00:09:27,960 --> 00:09:31,860
I don't know whether you remember Kerry. And there were there were.

71
00:09:31,860 --> 00:09:38,010
Do you really want to trade book? I didn't want anything academic, and we thought that was not a very good fit for us.

72
00:09:38,010 --> 00:09:43,850
We wanted to to be truthful to, you know, our community, academic community.

73
00:09:43,850 --> 00:09:52,780
And also that's the way we work while making it understandable and enjoyable for non academics.

74
00:09:52,780 --> 00:09:57,930
But we didn't want to write something that would be only trade.

75
00:09:57,930 --> 00:10:01,020
So Harvard was really kind of a good, good fit for us.

76
00:10:01,020 --> 00:10:10,080
But it was, of course, a challenge for me because it was the first time I was writing with somebody, even though we had to collaborate on that.

77
00:10:10,080 --> 00:10:17,610
On that application, writing a book was a little bit daunting. Plus, the fact that we were far away, I moved to the United States.

78
00:10:17,610 --> 00:10:32,200
But we I think that's we're very happy with how things went and we managed to I feel kind of unite our voices in a way that was not disjointed.

79
00:10:32,200 --> 00:10:39,780
Yeah. And I let Carey talk a little bit about the book. Uh, and then I'll come back.

80
00:10:39,780 --> 00:10:48,060
Thank you, Frank. Well, I thought perhaps I should start by just running through the chapter headings,

81
00:10:48,060 --> 00:10:52,650
if you like, because most of the audience here won't have read the book.

82
00:10:52,650 --> 00:11:02,790
Only the panellists have. And so it's got an introduction, which is more or less kind about on the political economy of the border.

83
00:11:02,790 --> 00:11:11,760
Its first chapter is about space and the very, very different ways that Russia and China organise space.

84
00:11:11,760 --> 00:11:23,040
It then homes in on an island in the middle of the Amazon River, which is half of it belongs to China and the other half belongs to Russia.

85
00:11:23,040 --> 00:11:25,080
So in one very small space,

86
00:11:25,080 --> 00:11:35,730
you can see some tremendously interesting contrasting ways that space has been handled and how it enters the politics of the places around it.

87
00:11:35,730 --> 00:11:40,410
Then we have a chapter called Making a Living in the Cross-border Economy.

88
00:11:40,410 --> 00:11:45,820
We have a chapter on indigenous peoples of the borderlands.

89
00:11:45,820 --> 00:11:54,770
We have another chapter on relationships across the border, which is called friends, foes and kin across the border.

90
00:11:54,770 --> 00:12:01,750
And we have another chapter on resources and environment, and we have a final chapter on the border cities,

91
00:12:01,750 --> 00:12:12,610
which is about imagination really, or the role of actuality and the imagination of how people see cities on either side.

92
00:12:12,610 --> 00:12:23,930
And then there's a kind of a coda. I thought I'd like to also say that during this project, a lot of things have appeared, I mean,

93
00:12:23,930 --> 00:12:29,450
I think when we started, we somewhere wrote in there that this is a relatively unstudied border.

94
00:12:29,450 --> 00:12:37,160
Well, that's not really true. No, there are really a lot of things.

95
00:12:37,160 --> 00:12:49,550
Frank has published a sign, a phobia book. We had a couple of books came out during the project, ones to the both of some sort of collections,

96
00:12:49,550 --> 00:12:56,410
one called Frontier Encounters and one called trust and mistrust in cross-border economies.

97
00:12:56,410 --> 00:13:05,050
And then several members of the project who published books and important articles are certain Urbanski book Beyond the Frontier,

98
00:13:05,050 --> 00:13:10,030
which is a really wonderful, detailed history.

99
00:13:10,030 --> 00:13:18,220
There's a conference book Merrylands, which has got it full of ethnographic insights and ethnic history.

100
00:13:18,220 --> 00:13:30,310
There's the tone. It's a formula, and it translates this wonderful book culture contact in a monkey land, which is very interesting.

101
00:13:30,310 --> 00:13:35,080
And the original book on Ivanka and Bourret relations.

102
00:13:35,080 --> 00:13:45,760
Then there's Natalia. Rizzo was immense contribution on economy and politics, and we really authoritative and insightful many articles.

103
00:13:45,760 --> 00:13:55,270
The Science and I'm Sarajevo's work, which she's done terrific work on the sort of trade and ethnic relations,

104
00:13:55,270 --> 00:14:00,740
and on the history of laborious exodus to Mongolia and China and Iran,

105
00:14:00,740 --> 00:14:09,280
Pascal's work on political history and Russian attitudes to to being on the border.

106
00:14:09,280 --> 00:14:17,140
So we actually refer to these books and articles, and we quote some of them,

107
00:14:17,140 --> 00:14:24,220
but we feel that it's all actually all out there in published and we really didn't want to replicate it.

108
00:14:24,220 --> 00:14:32,200
So as far as possible in the book, we focus on other aspects and in the main we use different ethnography.

109
00:14:32,200 --> 00:14:37,930
And quite a lot of it comes from internet sources because in the last year or two,

110
00:14:37,930 --> 00:14:45,310
we couldn't go there, obviously, and we needed, on the other hand, we felt we needed to be up to date.

111
00:14:45,310 --> 00:14:54,970
So we did get a lot from the internet, and I should mention that our fieldwork was done at different places and time.

112
00:14:54,970 --> 00:15:06,430
So Frank draws on his extended fieldwork in blog versions and figure two cities across the river.

113
00:15:06,430 --> 00:15:17,650
And I used rather brief for fieldwork that I've done in the Kolkata region and around there on the Zoback Ask area and in Mongolia,

114
00:15:17,650 --> 00:15:20,620
in China, and Shanahan, which is nearby.

115
00:15:20,620 --> 00:15:30,610
And then I pass through Genji, and when Chen was at Fulford, and then I went on to do some research in Vladivostok,

116
00:15:30,610 --> 00:15:36,160
where I focussed on real estate speculation and I've published separately on that.

117
00:15:36,160 --> 00:15:46,030
It's not in this book. So I think as a result of all that sort of you consider a complicated set up behind this book.

118
00:15:46,030 --> 00:15:57,190
It may seem to be patchy, and I think Frank got a little bit more to say about patchiness.

119
00:15:57,190 --> 00:16:03,970
Yeah. So I think this what could come across as banshees because we looked at we decided

120
00:16:03,970 --> 00:16:08,650
on what aspects of the interface between Russia and China wanted to look at.

121
00:16:08,650 --> 00:16:13,300
And of course, different authors might have selected other things.

122
00:16:13,300 --> 00:16:20,170
We decided on the basis, first of all, of our strengths and knowledge,

123
00:16:20,170 --> 00:16:26,620
but also on on themes that we thought were really crucial to understand the interaction between the two things

124
00:16:26,620 --> 00:16:34,450
that themes that came up regularly when we talked to people important things like the environment or space or,

125
00:16:34,450 --> 00:16:42,400
you know, danger from, especially from the Russian perspective. So we tried to hone in on those things.

126
00:16:42,400 --> 00:16:44,950
But of course, there's other things we could have written.

127
00:16:44,950 --> 00:16:52,360
I mean, anything comprehensive or close to comprehensiveness would have been like a huge, you know, huge volume.

128
00:16:52,360 --> 00:17:04,330
So we wanted to provide kind of a good understanding of this interaction interface between the two in ways that would be,

129
00:17:04,330 --> 00:17:10,270
you know, that would speak to to the reality and also to to this to the readers.

130
00:17:10,270 --> 00:17:15,820
And also, as Carrie said, we didn't want to replicate the wonderful work that's been done by our colleagues.

131
00:17:15,820 --> 00:17:23,530
So we kind of acknowledge it, but try to talk, you know, in between those things.

132
00:17:23,530 --> 00:17:27,190
But generally, I think any kind of any work of that nature,

133
00:17:27,190 --> 00:17:35,440
looking at the border between two huge countries like Russia and China would have to be patchy because there is not a single.

134
00:17:35,440 --> 00:17:41,230
It's not a unique vocal situation.

135
00:17:41,230 --> 00:17:50,260
You have really different set of actors and people would have different ideas about both themselves and the other and their relationship,

136
00:17:50,260 --> 00:17:55,740
depending on their and their background. Social, background, economic.

137
00:17:55,740 --> 00:18:01,140
Around gender, the only experience with the other side.

138
00:18:01,140 --> 00:18:09,750
So we really wanted to actually have that multifocal aspect.

139
00:18:09,750 --> 00:18:15,180
We wanted to go against this kind of top down accounts of what Moscow,

140
00:18:15,180 --> 00:18:20,670
Moscow and Beijing are saying, and I wanted to really look at what's happening on the ground.

141
00:18:20,670 --> 00:18:25,380
So that's so maybe that that's what could come across as bad.

142
00:18:25,380 --> 00:18:32,640
She's actually part of the design, I would say. OK, well, thank you, Frank.

143
00:18:32,640 --> 00:18:37,200
I'm just going to say a few words about the book in relation to emptiness.

144
00:18:37,200 --> 00:18:42,310
No, because I'm taking part in this roundtable made me think about it.

145
00:18:42,310 --> 00:18:48,180
We weren't, of course, thinking about emptiness specifically when we wrote the book,

146
00:18:48,180 --> 00:18:57,820
but I think that it does speak to the idea in three ways, and this probably will not come as a surprise to you.

147
00:18:57,820 --> 00:19:10,350
All could have been talking about it for three days, but maybe we can think of emptiness as first as a substance and secondly as a kind of withdrawal.

148
00:19:10,350 --> 00:19:14,910
And thirdly, as a kind of unintended product.

149
00:19:14,910 --> 00:19:21,690
And I think our book illustrates these three ideas in many ways.

150
00:19:21,690 --> 00:19:29,220
So in terms of absence of some definite thing that's been set up somewhere else.

151
00:19:29,220 --> 00:19:41,130
I think that the chapter chapter one, in fact, that discusses the structural gaps that appear in the Ruderman model,

152
00:19:41,130 --> 00:19:57,580
this idea of the sort of hyper typical high percent centralised system of administration and infrastructure in Russia.

153
00:19:57,580 --> 00:20:04,810
Creates in its industries a sense of absence and emptiness.

154
00:20:04,810 --> 00:20:15,670
And then we do also discuss withdrawal in well exemplified by the demise really

155
00:20:15,670 --> 00:20:22,600
overall the closing down of industries and facilities and occupations and services.

156
00:20:22,600 --> 00:20:31,480
And so that kind of emptiness is perhaps that of having nothing but a memory left of all these things.

157
00:20:31,480 --> 00:20:39,010
And then thirdly, I think we can think of emptiness as a kind of chasm that's produced and has

158
00:20:39,010 --> 00:20:49,080
unintended effects despite what looks like activity to create something positive.

159
00:20:49,080 --> 00:20:53,940
That's a bit like what an economist might call an externality.

160
00:20:53,940 --> 00:21:02,780
So here I'm thinking of something like the Eastern Economic Union Forum that happens regularly between China and Russia,

161
00:21:02,780 --> 00:21:13,110
the deciding on economic collaboration. And we mention how you know there will be speeches and declarations and ceremony.

162
00:21:13,110 --> 00:21:23,700
But the actual effect is to create a kind of haziness and unclarity that makes it difficult to actually implement anything.

163
00:21:23,700 --> 00:21:31,980
And I think another example might be if we turn again to the island in the middle of the Amil River,

164
00:21:31,980 --> 00:21:38,430
the kind of extravagant promises made on both sides and particularly the Russian side.

165
00:21:38,430 --> 00:21:48,750
But if nobody believes them that there are kind of hot-air and then what that produces is an immediate future,

166
00:21:48,750 --> 00:21:54,630
that's a kind of empty gap for the people who live around the.

167
00:21:54,630 --> 00:22:04,630
And then finally, I think I'd like to go back to the thing that Dom mentioned at the beginning that the question of these.

168
00:22:04,630 --> 00:22:14,350
Absent or no, the presence of bridges that don't actually serve or join Russia and China.

169
00:22:14,350 --> 00:22:21,400
I think it's a fantastic topic to think about in relation to emptiness.

170
00:22:21,400 --> 00:22:31,090
I think you're one of the things that comes out is the time specific nature of different kinds of emptiness.

171
00:22:31,090 --> 00:22:39,100
So for 20 or 30 years, these bridges were planned and all sorts of meetings about them, but they were constantly delayed.

172
00:22:39,100 --> 00:22:44,560
And I think you can think about that in terms of Rodman's model,

173
00:22:44,560 --> 00:22:53,410
this kind of structural absence that documents on borders at the edges of administrative areas.

174
00:22:53,410 --> 00:22:57,970
And in this case, of course, the border is a closed zone.

175
00:22:57,970 --> 00:23:07,080
Or was it closed or still is it closed zone and it's across a highly militarised international border?

176
00:23:07,080 --> 00:23:12,300
Now, what happened while we were writing the book is that they actually built two of these bridges,

177
00:23:12,300 --> 00:23:20,850
one of them Railway Bridge, and the other one is both a railway and the road bridge, but they still don't.

178
00:23:20,850 --> 00:23:30,510
There's still not quite open. And here I think we can again think about emptiness.

179
00:23:30,510 --> 00:23:41,760
And I think Alessandra Ripa's probably written about this kind of thing, too if we learn from other border crossings around China.

180
00:23:41,760 --> 00:23:49,350
It seems that these bridges are likely to be open for some people or for some companies and not for others,

181
00:23:49,350 --> 00:23:54,390
and that they may well open and then they may close again because they're on the border

182
00:23:54,390 --> 00:23:59,760
and the FSB may decide they're going to close it and then they may open it again.

183
00:23:59,760 --> 00:24:11,460
And so. You get to a kind of construct that in rhetoric is the great link between these two peoples,

184
00:24:11,460 --> 00:24:16,800
and if you look on the internet, that's the way it is described Russia and China coming together.

185
00:24:16,800 --> 00:24:28,470
But in fact, you're going to kind of profiting off by the fact of the lack of accessibility and this temporal uncertainty.

186
00:24:28,470 --> 00:24:41,340
And I think even if the bridge is open fully, I think the book as a whole kind of would support, especially its later chapters works.

187
00:24:41,340 --> 00:24:55,560
Morton Pedersen has done in Mongolia or roads with Michael Bloomberg, who's arguing that basically roads can paradoxically separate people.

188
00:24:55,560 --> 00:25:08,180
And in his us, it's a graphic case. These are mines built by the Chinese in Mongolia, roads linking the mines and oil fields to the border.

189
00:25:08,180 --> 00:25:10,410
Then take this stuff out.

190
00:25:10,410 --> 00:25:19,770
And the Mongolian herders either avoid using these roads or if they do, they say they haven't or they're kind of blank it out.

191
00:25:19,770 --> 00:25:30,630
And the argument basically is that because of the relationship they actually have with the Chinese, it's not a non-related.

192
00:25:30,630 --> 00:25:41,010
There is a relationship, but it's the relation of keeping distance, a relationship kind of disjuncture rather than adherence.

193
00:25:41,010 --> 00:25:51,990
And so these roads, what they do is they prioritise a sort of single minded capitalist economic relationship.

194
00:25:51,990 --> 00:26:05,460
But what they do is to kind of prevent really sort of untidy, indeterminate sort of multifaceted, possibly on the sort of non to legal side.

195
00:26:05,460 --> 00:26:10,910
So the assemblage of relations between the Chinese and the Mongolians.

196
00:26:10,910 --> 00:26:14,780
And it seems that the government is on both sides,

197
00:26:14,780 --> 00:26:19,040
the Chinese and Mongolian government very happy with it being like that because

198
00:26:19,040 --> 00:26:24,810
they both think that separation is the best way to avoid inter-ethnic conflict.

199
00:26:24,810 --> 00:26:32,860
I think our book provides many different instances of that kind of thing, which I really,

200
00:26:32,860 --> 00:26:38,760
really don't have time to go into, but I think there is a lot of evidence of that kind of thing.

201
00:26:38,760 --> 00:26:49,270
It's a relationship, but one of disjuncture, which I think you could see as a kind of emptiness.

202
00:26:49,270 --> 00:26:57,130
Yeah, and I think this this point of avoidant behaviour is something we see in infrastructure,

203
00:26:57,130 --> 00:27:02,440
for instance, in the organisation of space there, you mentioned the bridge.

204
00:27:02,440 --> 00:27:11,530
So one of them, the one that is being talked about for 30 years now between black or Asian, is going to take her going to exist.

205
00:27:11,530 --> 00:27:17,200
But it doesn't link the two towns directly have to go around.

206
00:27:17,200 --> 00:27:23,740
And then it would not be open to the public. True, true civilians.

207
00:27:23,740 --> 00:27:30,100
I mean, to to anybody wanting to travel across, it's really kind of for goods.

208
00:27:30,100 --> 00:27:31,840
And it's really kind of highly regulated.

209
00:27:31,840 --> 00:27:38,740
So there's always this element, even in the connexion between the two, there's this element of avoidance that is always there.

210
00:27:38,740 --> 00:27:49,510
And thinking also about import export things coming from China to true blood relations just across the river tends to travel around,

211
00:27:49,510 --> 00:27:58,510
you know, yes, quotas imposed on them has tariffs, and he travels all the way west before coming back.

212
00:27:58,510 --> 00:28:05,020
So they're becoming quite expensive. So there's always there are these connexions, but they are not direct connexions.

213
00:28:05,020 --> 00:28:15,070
And I think that kind of leads to this feeling of emptiness that we all can also think about

214
00:28:15,070 --> 00:28:20,470
close to zones like gulags and nuclear facilities as things we would have loved to work on.

215
00:28:20,470 --> 00:28:27,430
But of course, it's it's very difficult for us to have any access to that, even for all four Russians.

216
00:28:27,430 --> 00:28:38,710
But he really kind of contributes to this element of non homogenous space, which I think is an interesting point to make.

217
00:28:38,710 --> 00:28:46,510
When you when you think of borders, kind of the general idea of the two states controlling the two,

218
00:28:46,510 --> 00:28:50,890
the two territories in a homogeneous way, all the way to the border.

219
00:28:50,890 --> 00:28:56,920
At the same time, you have these holes, these gaps in in.

220
00:28:56,920 --> 00:29:03,250
Maybe not in sovereignty, but in access. I think that's that's an important point to make.

221
00:29:03,250 --> 00:29:11,440
And this so that that kind of brings us to this idea of emptiness, connecting to remoteness.

222
00:29:11,440 --> 00:29:21,750
And as something that we mentioned in the book The Way My People especially, I mean, actually on both sides, on both sides.

223
00:29:21,750 --> 00:29:29,470
Speaking of their location on the border and kind of being on the edge for Russians,

224
00:29:29,470 --> 00:29:35,290
it feels like they often talk about their town being kind of at the end of the world,

225
00:29:35,290 --> 00:29:42,850
like on the edge of everything, even though they are just across the border from a very dynamic country like China.

226
00:29:42,850 --> 00:29:55,600
For Chinese, it's also an edge in the sense of a window to look beyond the states, which is not always easy for Chinese to have access to.

227
00:29:55,600 --> 00:30:06,010
So you have tourists coming to America and looking at the other side, so you really have this sense of disjuncture and and remoteness embedded in it.

228
00:30:06,010 --> 00:30:11,830
And in a way, that's why we wanted to do the book with a book title. And that's that's something we worked on a lot.

229
00:30:11,830 --> 00:30:14,470
We spent so much time trying to find the right title,

230
00:30:14,470 --> 00:30:23,050
and I think we have because I think on the edge really kind of plays with this idea of the edge of the state,

231
00:30:23,050 --> 00:30:30,070
but also it kind of includes this, this sense of being on edge.

232
00:30:30,070 --> 00:30:38,210
So kind of this anxiety element to it, but also on edge on the edge.

233
00:30:38,210 --> 00:30:40,900
There's also kind of the link of being on the cusp,

234
00:30:40,900 --> 00:30:50,830
this kind of a more dynamic also sense of being on the cusp of something happening so that it's not just, you know, kind of very static.

235
00:30:50,830 --> 00:30:57,100
So I think this that the title plays with this kind of three different ideas of the edge.

236
00:30:57,100 --> 00:31:03,910
And and I think that will conclude our little introduction of the book and we look

237
00:31:03,910 --> 00:31:09,730
forward to hearing the the and the thoughts of the three readers and their questions.

238
00:31:09,730 --> 00:31:16,780
Well, thank you for that thought provoking introduction and first comments,

239
00:31:16,780 --> 00:31:24,490
and I think we should move straight into our responses and I thought we would go by alphabetical order.

240
00:31:24,490 --> 00:31:32,250
So Madeline, would you like to see your your piece and your thoughts?

241
00:31:32,250 --> 00:31:36,180
Sure. Can you hear me OK? Yeah. Great. Thank you.

242
00:31:36,180 --> 00:31:45,090
Thank you so much for the invitation to read and engage with Frank and Caroline's fascinating and I think, really expansive new book.

243
00:31:45,090 --> 00:31:49,050
And I think my comments actually follow up a lot from some of the themes that have

244
00:31:49,050 --> 00:31:55,140
already discussed this idea of non homogenous space and and the idea of gaps.

245
00:31:55,140 --> 00:32:00,750
So given the constraints of time and the focus of our workshop on emptiness and our modes of apprehending,

246
00:32:00,750 --> 00:32:09,360
it's I'm going to direct my comments to three themes that are raised for me by the book that I hope are pertinent to this wider workshop discussion.

247
00:32:09,360 --> 00:32:16,950
So the first concern is exactly the question of the institutional and infrastructural production of variegated space.

248
00:32:16,950 --> 00:32:21,850
The second concerns the relationship between emptiness and the movements of capital.

249
00:32:21,850 --> 00:32:32,020
And the third concern is what we might call sensing or seeing emptiness of the relationship between emptiness, ethnography and the visual.

250
00:32:32,020 --> 00:32:37,940
So first on the production of emptiness, and these will necessarily be pretty telegraphic points given the constraints of time,

251
00:32:37,940 --> 00:32:46,750
but a recurrent theme in the book and it's one that Frank and Carey have alluded to already in their comments,

252
00:32:46,750 --> 00:32:50,230
concerns what we might call the variegated, or, as Frank puts it,

253
00:32:50,230 --> 00:32:57,520
the non homogenous institutional presence thing of capitalism after socialism, Russia and China.

254
00:32:57,520 --> 00:33:04,120
We learnt on the first page, unlike all the way down and to their very peripheries,

255
00:33:04,120 --> 00:33:10,900
and we see this in the various chapters in the countries respective cultures of capitalism in chapter three,

256
00:33:10,900 --> 00:33:16,930
in contrasting memories of forced dislocation in Chapter four and divergent systems of tributes

257
00:33:16,930 --> 00:33:24,550
and trade in Chapter six and in contrasting hierarchies of spatial organisation in chapter one.

258
00:33:24,550 --> 00:33:33,490
And in developing this argument, the authors challenge both conventional assumptions that all illiberal states are illiberal in the same way and

259
00:33:33,490 --> 00:33:43,070
Eurocentric readings of state formation grounded in localised histories of territory and its political legal production.

260
00:33:43,070 --> 00:33:48,940
And as the authors have said and an astonishing alluded to in his comments, this is sort of explicitly not a theoretical book,

261
00:33:48,940 --> 00:33:54,850
but I think there were really significant theoretical implications for argument say about the

262
00:33:54,850 --> 00:34:01,610
history of territory which have tended to be written from a very Eurocentric perspective.

263
00:34:01,610 --> 00:34:08,750
So the authors show, for instance, that even as China has invested heavily in roads connecting small border towns

264
00:34:08,750 --> 00:34:13,400
and villages and has actively sought to populate its northern peripheries,

265
00:34:13,400 --> 00:34:22,580
Russia's radio model in which distance from Moscow and from provincial centres is what matters in the nesting hierarchy of connectivity,

266
00:34:22,580 --> 00:34:27,500
has allowed large swathes of land and significant rural populations to be

267
00:34:27,500 --> 00:34:33,800
literally and metaphorically bypassed from wider economic and political currents.

268
00:34:33,800 --> 00:34:39,740
Indeed, we learn that most border villages are disconnected from the recently constructed Amwell Highway,

269
00:34:39,740 --> 00:34:47,000
creating communities the targets, the authors put it, marooned at the end of their own transport spurs.

270
00:34:47,000 --> 00:34:51,650
This maroon, moreover, is at least in part intentional, if not habitual.

271
00:34:51,650 --> 00:35:00,050
The Russian authorities we see are profoundly sceptical about too much connectivity with their much more densely populated neighbour.

272
00:35:00,050 --> 00:35:04,520
The annual river has historically been conceived as a sacrosanct closure for Russia in the author's

273
00:35:04,520 --> 00:35:12,230
work words a marker of a civilizational boundary rather than a source of contact and exchange.

274
00:35:12,230 --> 00:35:20,840
And today, this results in a variety of phantom projects that haunt the present, not just these sort of partially constructed or constructed,

275
00:35:20,840 --> 00:35:24,260
but unopened bridges that Caroline mentioned,

276
00:35:24,260 --> 00:35:35,390
but also docking ports that have no boats to dock at them or so-called territories of advance development that can't attract employees.

277
00:35:35,390 --> 00:35:40,760
So there's this kind of constant deferral of connectivity. China, meanwhile,

278
00:35:40,760 --> 00:35:49,790
is busily stressing that the Great Wall constitutes less a boundary between different civilisations than the cradle of communication and fusion,

279
00:35:49,790 --> 00:35:58,550
as well as actively investing in a miniaturised and sanitised version of Russian culture for sale to inland tourists in Kihei.

280
00:35:58,550 --> 00:36:00,110
As the authors show, moreover,

281
00:36:00,110 --> 00:36:07,460
this isn't just a story of connectivity on one side of a vast international border and an absence of such connexion on the other.

282
00:36:07,460 --> 00:36:12,380
We might in Caroline's kind of tripartite sort of passing of ideas, emptiness.

283
00:36:12,380 --> 00:36:19,850
We might think of different forms of emptiness that are produced on either side of the border because we see, for instance,

284
00:36:19,850 --> 00:36:29,060
how China's very ambition to create connexion to distant land and seaports through the Belt and Road Initiative creates new kinds of disconnection,

285
00:36:29,060 --> 00:36:35,420
new forms of economic stratification and perhaps new experiences of estrangement places rendered

286
00:36:35,420 --> 00:36:41,260
newly remote or unreachable by the channelling of transport past rather than through them.

287
00:36:41,260 --> 00:36:48,850
Emptiness, just like disconnection, it seems, is the product of action and inaction rather than a pre-existing state.

288
00:36:48,850 --> 00:36:50,140
And just like disconnection,

289
00:36:50,140 --> 00:36:58,790
it can be amplified by the very discourses and practises that promote connectivity and consumption as markers of modernity.

290
00:36:58,790 --> 00:37:01,790
This gets me to my first cluster of questions for the authors,

291
00:37:01,790 --> 00:37:08,390
which concerns how he makes sense of the political logic of Russia's policy of Maru Ning and how we square this with,

292
00:37:08,390 --> 00:37:15,620
say, active programmes of resettlement for so-called compatriots Satechi's Sinicki to the Russian Far East.

293
00:37:15,620 --> 00:37:24,710
I'm also curious to know about how the evident ambivalence about the connexion plays out within different parts of the Russian state.

294
00:37:24,710 --> 00:37:33,710
The book stresses the centralised and hierarchies nature of the Russian polity in this kind of radial formation other than but in domains such as,

295
00:37:33,710 --> 00:37:34,970
say, migration policy.

296
00:37:34,970 --> 00:37:43,220
That's quite a lot of divergence at a provincial level and often discrepancy between the political agendas of different government ministries,

297
00:37:43,220 --> 00:37:49,130
as well as between federal and provincial authorities. So I'm curious to know how this is manifest, for instance,

298
00:37:49,130 --> 00:37:56,390
in the question of whether or not to open the long heralded bridge across the M4 or what to do with those Napier's given these Chawla,

299
00:37:56,390 --> 00:38:02,120
those futureless villages that haven't been earmarked for special economic development.

300
00:38:02,120 --> 00:38:08,050
I'm curious to know where and in what forms do those acts of abandonment contested?

301
00:38:08,050 --> 00:38:17,670
My second set of comments, in part prompted by these questions, relate to the relationship between emptiness and the economy at different scales.

302
00:38:17,670 --> 00:38:21,240
The authors describe the book as patchy, and I wouldn't have described it that way,

303
00:38:21,240 --> 00:38:29,490
but it seems to me too that it occupies two registers simultaneously or perhaps to adopt the visual metaphor of our conference.

304
00:38:29,490 --> 00:38:36,000
It seems to me that it shifts in its mode of seeing between a wide angled and a much more focussed lens.

305
00:38:36,000 --> 00:38:43,020
On the one hand, there's an intervention into an Anglophone public debate that tends to exaggerate similarities

306
00:38:43,020 --> 00:38:49,290
between Russia and China and disregard altogether the places where these two First Nations meet.

307
00:38:49,290 --> 00:38:53,760
And here, as Dominic has already alluded to, the authors pull no punches.

308
00:38:53,760 --> 00:38:59,280
The long border between the two gigantic, nationalistic oriented countries, the authors argue,

309
00:38:59,280 --> 00:39:06,720
is, I quote not merely a line between two countries, but between two entirely different worlds.

310
00:39:06,720 --> 00:39:13,350
And yet, the book also inhabits a different kind of register, one more traditionally associated with ethnography,

311
00:39:13,350 --> 00:39:22,080
in which the specificity of particular lives with all the contingencies of biography, history, love, friendship, curiosity and so on.

312
00:39:22,080 --> 00:39:31,560
Lead to quite different kinds of insight about intensive, unregulated practises of trade, about borrowing and mimi friendship and adventure.

313
00:39:31,560 --> 00:39:40,890
About long, expensive and uncomfortable journeys to sacred sites but cannot be reduced to any simple economic rationality speaks a much

314
00:39:40,890 --> 00:39:49,510
more encompassing sense of historical mythical connexion and incorporation of time measured in generations rather than years.

315
00:39:49,510 --> 00:39:56,110
Moreover, while it's clear that Russian leaders and policymakers view too much connexion with China with some trepidation,

316
00:39:56,110 --> 00:40:02,500
we also see how the very fact of spatial and social variation creates new opportunities for connexion.

317
00:40:02,500 --> 00:40:09,640
A new exigencies to mobilise different regimes of value as a matter perhaps of economic survival.

318
00:40:09,640 --> 00:40:18,430
Exigencies that operate amidst vestiges from the past where the physical ruins human habits or memories of forced displacement.

319
00:40:18,430 --> 00:40:19,690
We see this, for instance,

320
00:40:19,690 --> 00:40:29,380
in new forms of sociality produced around the illegal trades in jade ore body or the body parts of bears or the fang fen root.

321
00:40:29,380 --> 00:40:35,890
I found these glimpses of contingent and unexpected collaboration, some of the most interesting parts of the book,

322
00:40:35,890 --> 00:40:39,640
and I'd like to ask the authors about the theoretical implications of these,

323
00:40:39,640 --> 00:40:48,160
both for our understanding of the differences that go all the way down and the possible ways in which such expectations of civilizational

324
00:40:48,160 --> 00:40:57,700
difference are refused by those whose family history or personal biography do not fall easily into binary national narratives.

325
00:40:57,700 --> 00:41:04,810
We get hints of this, for instance, in the varying attitudes towards the Chinese and black efficiency inflected by family

326
00:41:04,810 --> 00:41:10,900
histories of trade or the desire for cultural connexion demonstrated by Buddhists and.

327
00:41:10,900 --> 00:41:15,190
But I'm interested in the implications of these forms of connexion.

328
00:41:15,190 --> 00:41:24,700
Sorry about the implications of these forms of connexion for the overarching argument that civilizational differences wrung both thick and deep.

329
00:41:24,700 --> 00:41:32,940
I'm curious to know, for instance, about the new forms of cross-border communication that are enabled by mobile technologies or by the

330
00:41:32,940 --> 00:41:39,150
consumption of forms of media uniting populations across the border originating from other elsewhere,

331
00:41:39,150 --> 00:41:46,170
such as K-pop, which seems to be popular, you know, throughout large parts of East and Central Asia.

332
00:41:46,170 --> 00:41:55,350
Do these forms of connexion have the potential to be truly disruptive or are they merely the exceptions that in a sense, prove the rule?

333
00:41:55,350 --> 00:41:59,850
This gets me to my final point, which relates to ways of seeing and other ways of knowing.

334
00:41:59,850 --> 00:42:09,400
And again, prompted by the sort of the theme of the conference and more generally on the relationship between emptiness, ethnography and aspect.

335
00:42:09,400 --> 00:42:16,570
In our ocular centric public culture, as several of the workshop presentations have shown,

336
00:42:16,570 --> 00:42:24,850
emptiness is paradigmatic fully conveyed through the visual field. We might think of the iconic scenes of abandoned Pripyat in the aftermath of

337
00:42:24,850 --> 00:42:29,740
the Chernobyl nuclear disaster or the urban vistas of Chinese ghost towns,

338
00:42:29,740 --> 00:42:37,390
figuring Sunday supplements, inviting the viewer to wonder if the hubris of a pristine, planned future.

339
00:42:37,390 --> 00:42:45,820
There's a lot of this visual field in the book, too. So for instance, we as the reader are invited like the readers of Russian.

340
00:42:45,820 --> 00:42:55,390
I must step out after to see and thus to wonder at the striking contrast between the waterfront scenes separating the two towns in the late 1980s.

341
00:42:55,390 --> 00:43:01,990
And today to look at the sort of Google Earth view of the different sides of the border.

342
00:43:01,990 --> 00:43:11,440
Likewise, we search participants in black. Officials can hear he were invited to draw, as well as to describe their impressions of the other side.

343
00:43:11,440 --> 00:43:14,980
And it was striking that many of the descriptions focussed on the contrasting

344
00:43:14,980 --> 00:43:19,940
visual aspects of the two cities or the visual impacts of the two cities.

345
00:43:19,940 --> 00:43:24,730
So the lights that came on at nine p.m. and seek to create a festive atmosphere.

346
00:43:24,730 --> 00:43:29,060
The grids over here and the sparkles over there and so forth.

347
00:43:29,060 --> 00:43:35,540
And this has got me to thinking about the particular relationship between different consumption and the visual field.

348
00:43:35,540 --> 00:43:41,420
I'm struck how much of the encounter that occurs at the border is one mediated through site,

349
00:43:41,420 --> 00:43:47,750
not just in the infrastructure of watchtowers and border barracks, but were intended both to see and to be seen,

350
00:43:47,750 --> 00:43:53,690
but also in the ways that border residents and visitors are invited to encounter and often sanitised version

351
00:43:53,690 --> 00:44:00,680
of difference by viewing it at a distance from a viewing platform or a raised walkway or a hotel window,

352
00:44:00,680 --> 00:44:09,070
or in a miniaturised kind of form for consumption. I'm curious to hear more about what the authors think is going on here,

353
00:44:09,070 --> 00:44:15,790
both in terms of the dynamics that are driving it and its implications for the way that difference across the border is experienced,

354
00:44:15,790 --> 00:44:24,940
felt and consumed, given in other words, to our informants as much as ourselves are inhabited by hyper mediated worlds.

355
00:44:24,940 --> 00:44:30,610
How is their own way of seeing shaped by heightened awareness of how others might see them?

356
00:44:30,610 --> 00:44:35,380
And given the ethnography too, is increasingly conducted in all sorts of mediated ways,

357
00:44:35,380 --> 00:44:39,310
and the authors alluded to this in their in their comments where we say,

358
00:44:39,310 --> 00:44:45,400
like our informants can wonder, the difference is exposed by Google Earth perspective on the border.

359
00:44:45,400 --> 00:44:52,390
Well, the vista from a multi-story hotel. What implications does this have for ethnography as embodied practise?

360
00:44:52,390 --> 00:44:56,620
In other words, can we how can we bring the tools of ethnography as a remote,

361
00:44:56,620 --> 00:45:08,110
as a mode of attentiveness that entails spatial proximity to forms of encountering that are themselves premised upon a suspension of such proximity?

362
00:45:08,110 --> 00:45:10,870
So I'm kind of curious about the implications of this argument,

363
00:45:10,870 --> 00:45:16,690
both for the thinking about the sort of the role of the visual in this mode of cross-border encounter,

364
00:45:16,690 --> 00:45:24,700
but also for how we kind of can conduct an ethnography of of these practises of obscene.

365
00:45:24,700 --> 00:45:34,840
So I leave it there. Thank you very much. Thank you, Madeleine, that wonderful comments, I'm sure we could spend the next hour just discussing that,

366
00:45:34,840 --> 00:45:42,220
but we have two other presentations that were sure adds even more food for thought.

367
00:45:42,220 --> 00:45:47,320
So, um, Alessandra, would you like to be next?

368
00:45:47,320 --> 00:45:53,920
Sure. Thank you. Hi, everyone, and thank you so much for inviting me to join this.

369
00:45:53,920 --> 00:46:01,090
This, this roundtable and this event. More broadly, I find the Old Emptiness Project really fascinating and relevant and timely,

370
00:46:01,090 --> 00:46:09,940
and I very much looking forward to following it over the next year and thank you for the opportunity to read on the edge and to sync with it.

371
00:46:09,940 --> 00:46:12,460
It really is an honour for me to be here,

372
00:46:12,460 --> 00:46:19,150
particularly as the work of both Colleen Humphrey and Frank P has been a source of constant inspiration for me

373
00:46:19,150 --> 00:46:26,980
over the years and still very much something that I look up to as an example of just brilliant anthropology.

374
00:46:26,980 --> 00:46:35,290
What to say of the book itself? I find it, and I see my comments are coming a little bit more from a China perspective.

375
00:46:35,290 --> 00:46:39,550
And I find it not just a great contribution to two border studies,

376
00:46:39,550 --> 00:46:45,790
but also two to two Chinese studies and a very timely contribution for three reasons.

377
00:46:45,790 --> 00:46:52,360
The first is academic. The China studies field is very much, I find in the process of reorienting itself,

378
00:46:52,360 --> 00:46:56,920
trying to move away from some of the methodological nationalism from some of

379
00:46:56,920 --> 00:47:01,690
the exceptionalism that that characterised much of its research in the past.

380
00:47:01,690 --> 00:47:08,800
And in this regard to the studies of global China, sudden studies of the impact of sort of Chinese investments,

381
00:47:08,800 --> 00:47:18,880
development growth across its borders and across the globe really are multiplying and I would very much least on the edge amongst those.

382
00:47:18,880 --> 00:47:25,120
Secondly, this book is particularly important in the current moment where very little ethnographic

383
00:47:25,120 --> 00:47:31,540
research in China is possible and probably won't be possible for for the time being.

384
00:47:31,540 --> 00:47:40,060
Which brings me to the third reason I see the book as a key contribution to China studies as because of the political situation.

385
00:47:40,060 --> 00:47:48,700
Today, I find a need for nuance takes based on careful, ethnographic work that can add some flesh to a growing,

386
00:47:48,700 --> 00:47:52,330
polarising discussion in opposition between China and the West again.

387
00:47:52,330 --> 00:47:58,870
This is very much needed. Anything on the edge accomplishes there accomplishes that.

388
00:47:58,870 --> 00:48:02,110
No, I'm not going to even try to summarise this work,

389
00:48:02,110 --> 00:48:09,580
but I want to go through three key points that the book raised and that caught my attention in particular.

390
00:48:09,580 --> 00:48:17,230
And I will try to phrase each point around the question so that we can have more of a discussion at the end.

391
00:48:17,230 --> 00:48:22,690
Let me start with an anecdote from a few years back when I was at another border

392
00:48:22,690 --> 00:48:28,090
of the of the PRC of the People's Republic of China near the town of Tanjung,

393
00:48:28,090 --> 00:48:37,660
Southwest China and Yunnan province, driving along a newly built road that followed more or less a section of the Myanmar border.

394
00:48:37,660 --> 00:48:41,830
We were just about some 20 kilometres away from the actual boundary line,

395
00:48:41,830 --> 00:48:48,520
and I was together with the local party official and we were visiting some of the entry points to which were Burmese.

396
00:48:48,520 --> 00:48:57,520
Timber was brought into China was sort of showing me around, and I remember asking him when that particular road we were travelling on was built

397
00:48:57,520 --> 00:49:03,250
as it was then feature on a map that I had bought just just shortly before that.

398
00:49:03,250 --> 00:49:08,740
And he told me that it was only recently built and that it was built as part of a project

399
00:49:08,740 --> 00:49:13,720
to build one single road that will run alongside the entire border of the country,

400
00:49:13,720 --> 00:49:19,000
from Yunnan to Tibet, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia and and the Northeast.

401
00:49:19,000 --> 00:49:27,790
Mm-Hmm. And so back in my room in the evening, I'm looking it up online and on the Chinese internet, and I couldn't really find any official.

402
00:49:27,790 --> 00:49:35,290
He entered that project, and I didn't really follow up much on that on that conversation, especially because I haven't heard about it since.

403
00:49:35,290 --> 00:49:41,650
Maybe my local friend came up with it. Maybe I just didn't look in the right place.

404
00:49:41,650 --> 00:49:47,230
Nevertheless, this particular road did this idea of this road that follows the border within China.

405
00:49:47,230 --> 00:49:54,550
So this truck struck a chord for how it explicitly sort of connected to kinds of infrastructure the border,

406
00:49:54,550 --> 00:50:01,480
an infrastructure of monitoring and containment, and the road and infrastructure of connectivity.

407
00:50:01,480 --> 00:50:09,220
Yet in this case, not of transnational connectivity. What is interesting about this road is that it doesn't cross the border.

408
00:50:09,220 --> 00:50:11,590
It connects places within China.

409
00:50:11,590 --> 00:50:21,970
It somewhat reinforces perhaps the state's territorial grip on its outermost regions, but doesn't ultimately contribute to cross-border mobility.

410
00:50:21,970 --> 00:50:27,720
And so this experience came back to me once again while reading your book and made me think how?

411
00:50:27,720 --> 00:50:35,610
In many border regions of China, the border, the proximity to the border doesn't really seem to matter too much.

412
00:50:35,610 --> 00:50:41,760
There are exceptions, of course, such as I heard that you describe in the book perhaps really the China Myanmar borderlands,

413
00:50:41,760 --> 00:50:45,570
not far from where I was sitting that to some extent.

414
00:50:45,570 --> 00:50:57,120
And you should add their own existence to the past 1980s, 1990s opening of these borders and and of the Chinese economy more broadly.

415
00:50:57,120 --> 00:51:02,730
But as soon as you move a little bit away from cities and in most parts along the Chinese side of the border,

416
00:51:02,730 --> 00:51:06,660
it seems to me that this proximity doesn't play much of a role.

417
00:51:06,660 --> 00:51:12,390
You write that in the case, in the case of Russia, that China is Russia's main trading partner,

418
00:51:12,390 --> 00:51:18,810
whereas Russia is only the 12th in China's list of partners and received less than two percent of its exports,

419
00:51:18,810 --> 00:51:23,880
well beyond world behind countries such as India, Singapore and the Netherlands.

420
00:51:23,880 --> 00:51:26,940
And this is true of all of China's land neighbours.

421
00:51:26,940 --> 00:51:33,600
Perhaps the only exception is India, but again, it's not much strange going on that the actual land border with India.

422
00:51:33,600 --> 00:51:40,530
And so I find it sort of unsurprising that when you discuss transnational economic activities like you do in Chapter three,

423
00:51:40,530 --> 00:51:48,720
you focus much more on activities within Russia, which seem to matter a lot more to local border population than than within China,

424
00:51:48,720 --> 00:51:57,980
which kind of makes me think that proximity to the border in China matters significantly less then than in those countries.

425
00:51:57,980 --> 00:52:01,200
That's what my question would be, whether you you agree with that,

426
00:52:01,200 --> 00:52:08,850
but also if this is just about a particular economic imbalance or does it also have to do

427
00:52:08,850 --> 00:52:14,700
with a particular cultural I would call it reluctant c on the Chinese side to openly,

428
00:52:14,700 --> 00:52:17,860
perhaps on equal terms, engage with the other side.

429
00:52:17,860 --> 00:52:25,260
It's something that you that you write about in the book that I'd like to sort of hear a little bit more.

430
00:52:25,260 --> 00:52:29,030
The second point, and I'm going to try to be to be brief, I would have many more points.

431
00:52:29,030 --> 00:52:32,070
Maybe I can add some questions during the Q&A later.

432
00:52:32,070 --> 00:52:42,420
But my second point is more of a question about sort of the book's contribution to the field of anthropology more than just Chinese studies.

433
00:52:42,420 --> 00:52:48,120
Is that something that that that Frank mentioned at the beginning that the book explicitly

434
00:52:48,120 --> 00:52:54,270
tries to avoid trying to capture this particular borderlands through a particular theme,

435
00:52:54,270 --> 00:53:01,140
such as you mentioned, neighbour, as you mentioned, madeleines border work and doesn't aim to theorise your findings,

436
00:53:01,140 --> 00:53:07,110
but also to foreground tomography and construct contextual analysis of these technocracy, of course.

437
00:53:07,110 --> 00:53:09,600
And I find it extremely refreshing.

438
00:53:09,600 --> 00:53:17,490
And one of the main reasons I really enjoyed reading the book so much, and you also avoid using theories from the outside.

439
00:53:17,490 --> 00:53:19,740
For instance, you don't speak like you mentioned, for example,

440
00:53:19,740 --> 00:53:25,020
Solomon's accumulation with reference to some of China's business interest in Russia's Far East.

441
00:53:25,020 --> 00:53:32,310
But you don't you don't go into that you resort instead to the analysis of a local political theorist, Leonid Blackhat.

442
00:53:32,310 --> 00:53:35,580
I'm sorry for mispronouncing. No, is it just me?

443
00:53:35,580 --> 00:53:44,610
Or this also hints at an invitation, perhaps toward some current anthropological literature in which theorising very often is given primacy

444
00:53:44,610 --> 00:53:51,150
over some graphic material and at times ends up obfuscating the quality of lived experience systems.

445
00:53:51,150 --> 00:53:53,010
How do you see this approach?

446
00:53:53,010 --> 00:54:01,950
Again, not so much as a criticism, but more of an invitation to step back a little bit from the need to theorise, generalise or to abstract.

447
00:54:01,950 --> 00:54:06,650
And the last point I want to make is about representation.

448
00:54:06,650 --> 00:54:12,660
And Carolyn was talking about imagination just at the beginning of the roundtable,

449
00:54:12,660 --> 00:54:19,800
and I'm thinking of representation or imaginations of the other in particular once again from the Chinese side,

450
00:54:19,800 --> 00:54:23,700
because on the one hand, you have the representation of the Russian observer.

451
00:54:23,700 --> 00:54:31,770
I'm thinking of your examples from Chapter seven, which have already been mentioned by Madeleine of the of the model Russian village,

452
00:54:31,770 --> 00:54:36,210
for instance, which you say is a largely positive image.

453
00:54:36,210 --> 00:54:39,750
But what an image that is not based on any real dialogue.

454
00:54:39,750 --> 00:54:45,750
And you show how the imaginary of Russia that the model Russian village projects has been filtered

455
00:54:45,750 --> 00:54:51,420
through the state narratives rather than representing the outcome of a lived experience.

456
00:54:51,420 --> 00:54:56,700
And this, to me, strikes a parallel with how indigenous groups are represented in China.

457
00:54:56,700 --> 00:55:02,820
You describe again model villages, which are built largely for tourism consumption on the Chinese side,

458
00:55:02,820 --> 00:55:08,190
in which particular indigenous tradition or ethnic minority tradition are invented.

459
00:55:08,190 --> 00:55:12,000
And to some extent, imposed upon such communities.

460
00:55:12,000 --> 00:55:18,510
And as someone who has been working in minority areas in Xinjiang and Yunnan, I can completely relate to this.

461
00:55:18,510 --> 00:55:24,270
Now, what was particularly interesting to me is the intersection of ecological,

462
00:55:24,270 --> 00:55:30,810
ethnographic and cultural heritage politics in China and the underlying connexion that you point out

463
00:55:30,810 --> 00:55:37,860
between minority communities and a certain idea of a natural environment that you can find within China.

464
00:55:37,860 --> 00:55:41,760
And yet, at the same time, again, these contradictions that it think again,

465
00:55:41,760 --> 00:55:48,240
Karen was sort of hinting at the same time, not only on the Chinese side of the border has been heavily developed,

466
00:55:48,240 --> 00:55:56,090
but also you have Chinese firms engaging in environmentally damaging businesses and the Russian side timber and so on.

467
00:55:56,090 --> 00:56:03,390
And so what is nature? What is this nature that is represented here in those model villages in this sort of

468
00:56:03,390 --> 00:56:10,800
composition of particular forms of indigenous is is this in itself another either?

469
00:56:10,800 --> 00:56:18,990
I was wondering if we could say of how this natural environment is represented in China, the same that you say of the Russian model villages,

470
00:56:18,990 --> 00:56:27,300
something that is largely positive, but that is not based on any real experience, something that is filtered by and through state narratives.

471
00:56:27,300 --> 00:56:33,930
Is this a parallel? Doesn't make sense. And maybe this is why there is no contradiction between simultaneous efforts to

472
00:56:33,930 --> 00:56:39,360
preserve both minority livelihoods and natural environments and to conserve

473
00:56:39,360 --> 00:56:44,730
nature in particular species and efforts to develop to extract and destroy the

474
00:56:44,730 --> 00:56:50,640
landscape and its non-human inhabitants for the processes of accumulation.

475
00:56:50,640 --> 00:57:00,790
And so I'll stop here and thank you again very much for this opportunity and congrats on the book.

476
00:57:00,790 --> 00:57:08,770
Thank you, Alexandra, fascinating insights and points there and really appreciate your perspective,

477
00:57:08,770 --> 00:57:16,780
and I'm sure Katy and Frank will come back to that. But finally, we have Natalia juva to share her point of view.

478
00:57:16,780 --> 00:57:20,980
So Natalia, can you come over to you?

479
00:57:20,980 --> 00:57:29,740
Thank you for inviting me to this talk to discuss Carolyn Frank's book and also thank you,

480
00:57:29,740 --> 00:57:33,670
Dominique, for encouraging me to share some of my ethnography.

481
00:57:33,670 --> 00:57:41,350
I mean, the only me, I'm going to present something I I, when I read this book,

482
00:57:41,350 --> 00:57:52,150
identify two issues which are really important for understanding the current situation on the Russian forests.

483
00:57:52,150 --> 00:58:04,510
It turns out that I don't entirely agree with the conclusions the authors came to on this on the first issue about emptiness,

484
00:58:04,510 --> 00:58:15,490
and I will explain why and how, and I would like to somewhat of the issue on the issue of cultural capitalism.

485
00:58:15,490 --> 00:58:28,930
So I built my presentation on these two issue. What I disagree is connected to the theme of the conference.

486
00:58:28,930 --> 00:58:39,550
The authors claim that Russia almost intentionally cultivate intentionally sorry cultivates alternatives in peripheral regions.

487
00:58:39,550 --> 00:58:44,200
The authors insist that Russia was to have liminal space to ensure security,

488
00:58:44,200 --> 00:58:54,670
while liminal space is produced through different access restrictions open and some closed this again and really, to some extent with this assertion.

489
00:58:54,670 --> 00:59:01,810
Nevertheless, I think Russia appears in such claim as a coherent will.

490
00:59:01,810 --> 00:59:09,700
However, let's suppose that different regional and federal governments and the very different population have the same,

491
00:59:09,700 --> 00:59:15,370
and we should agree that the somewhat irrational understanding of security

492
00:59:15,370 --> 00:59:21,040
and coldness and have the same desire to create empty space along the border.

493
00:59:21,040 --> 00:59:28,000
But in this case, one needs to explain how such coherence is achieved.

494
00:59:28,000 --> 00:59:38,590
I am afraid I disagree with the coherence of the same perception of security or closeness may arise, probably,

495
00:59:38,590 --> 00:59:47,050
but it would result from a complex interweaving of rational incentives and maybe not entirely rational attitudes.

496
00:59:47,050 --> 00:59:57,400
I do illustrate my comments with a small, ethnographic case the Book of Mormon, chants of the City of Subordinate and the thoughts of Ski.

497
00:59:57,400 --> 01:00:00,160
It said that Zettl was created based on MacGregor's,

498
01:00:00,160 --> 01:00:09,070
but it doesn't say that the was created based on the secret global settlement, which rules for bodily iTeam surroundings.

499
01:00:09,070 --> 01:00:15,070
For Woodley, where Zuma has a secret settlement subordinate to you long or you see them on the map.

500
01:00:15,070 --> 01:00:26,750
And actually, my ethnography based mainly on subordinate 21 in Soviet times nuclear warheads was taught in probably to world,

501
01:00:26,750 --> 01:00:33,130
while in sublimely 18 meaningful missiles.

502
01:00:33,130 --> 01:00:41,710
Although military surrounding space will still preserve the infrastructure, barracks, officers, buildings, even clinics,

503
01:00:41,710 --> 01:00:50,510
schools and kindergartens, and the government decided to use the former sabudana 18 for Bazardo and Cosmodrome.

504
01:00:50,510 --> 01:00:53,080
Actually, the book mentioned this story.

505
01:00:53,080 --> 01:01:03,070
The residence of Subordinate 20, while remained remain utterly, may also hold that something valuable would be placed in their old tome.

506
01:01:03,070 --> 01:01:10,630
One of the auction was that Gazprom would accommodate builders and then employees of Advanced Development Zone.

507
01:01:10,630 --> 01:01:14,380
The regional administration are strongly supportive of this idea.

508
01:01:14,380 --> 01:01:21,250
Most importantly, the people who State Duma February 21 dreamed of such an opportunity,

509
01:01:21,250 --> 01:01:27,760
including the skilled migrants from Turkey, would come to life in this race.

510
01:01:27,760 --> 01:01:34,540
As a result, the town would find that we totally keys to be called dreams about Darleen.

511
01:01:34,540 --> 01:01:41,320
We would not come to Gazprom House or is it in place in a completely new space?

512
01:01:41,320 --> 01:01:49,540
However, it spoils for me or how people on this are two very similar Janelle.

513
01:01:49,540 --> 01:01:57,040
Logically related towns felt about emptiness and the occupancy of the people in Neveldine.

514
01:01:57,040 --> 01:02:04,940
They were eager to have the tunnel filled because. Otherwise they were in danger of becoming imagine the West Village and the

515
01:02:04,940 --> 01:02:10,880
people in Sokolski were happy to remain closed and therefore relatively empty.

516
01:02:10,880 --> 01:02:15,500
Hala, was there any irrationality in this case?

517
01:02:15,500 --> 01:02:20,810
I mean, this story left I I think so. Returning to coherency,

518
01:02:20,810 --> 01:02:29,510
people in Sokolski were angry with the central government while locals are leaving the local hero with the regional government.

519
01:02:29,510 --> 01:02:42,930
Moreover, was. Sokolski, even ordinary situations has a unique you most cases, Russian swimming, military balance, all frontier garrisons.

520
01:02:42,930 --> 01:02:53,130
Our secret towns are not even tonight to share the faith of family, but the fate of of empty dying regional spaces.

521
01:02:53,130 --> 01:03:06,870
At the same time, most not all, but most new development zone, like a war zone through territorial development are built on entirely empty new places.

522
01:03:06,870 --> 01:03:18,330
And I agree with Caroline, who proposed a long time ago in our conversation that could use an empty space for development

523
01:03:18,330 --> 01:03:24,120
of the Russian governmental perception of people and managing and controlling the Russian front.

524
01:03:24,120 --> 01:03:28,800
This perception and actions actually irritate the population very much,

525
01:03:28,800 --> 01:03:37,830
and people simultaneously see empty and crumbling tunnels and new facilities not connected with them.

526
01:03:37,830 --> 01:03:42,810
So that again, is a point about incoherence.

527
01:03:42,810 --> 01:03:54,810
I assume you so if you put on and you see the people in government have a coherent policy or coherent understanding of Clinton,

528
01:03:54,810 --> 01:04:02,460
both create an empty space on the periphery. What is the apparatus for achieving such a coherence?

529
01:04:02,460 --> 01:04:07,290
That's my first question. Yeah, I was told that he ended.

530
01:04:07,290 --> 01:04:12,900
The second one is about the culture of capitalism.

531
01:04:12,900 --> 01:04:18,600
The book argues that such cultures in Russia and China are totally different.

532
01:04:18,600 --> 01:04:26,650
Seventy years of anti-capitalism of the USSR resulted in building modern Russian capitalism on the remnants of collectivism.

533
01:04:26,650 --> 01:04:35,100
And incidentally, unlike China, which was lucky enough to build its version of capitalism and simple everyday commerce,

534
01:04:35,100 --> 01:04:42,090
the also the authors also argued that Russia has chosen a nearly liberal version of capitalism,

535
01:04:42,090 --> 01:04:50,970
and the discussions of the culture of capitalism in the book include rural ethnography and Chinese farmers and the Russian words.

536
01:04:50,970 --> 01:04:56,210
I have some with my graphic observation, which I want to introduce before asking my question.

537
01:04:56,210 --> 01:05:03,810
So with my colleague, who finished the paper and revealed how the big Russian migrant holding came to

538
01:05:03,810 --> 01:05:10,380
the city crime three years ago by a cloud farm by China is a great audience.

539
01:05:10,380 --> 01:05:20,130
For over a decade, Chinese and Russian who are the holders of, I would say, antagonistic structures and culture.

540
01:05:20,130 --> 01:05:32,100
The rest of the world has a vertical organisation. However, it is controlled by a single centre, while China's one has a horizontal structure,

541
01:05:32,100 --> 01:05:38,280
which looks like there is no structure to just small Chinese farmers who work separately.

542
01:05:38,280 --> 01:05:39,030
In the paper,

543
01:05:39,030 --> 01:05:50,060
we argue that the Russian hold them would not have entered the region if previously China's target of holding would not rent land shares from small,

544
01:05:50,060 --> 01:05:55,710
rational local horse holders. In other words,

545
01:05:55,710 --> 01:06:06,210
I assume that the Chinese culture of capitalism was much more suited to coping with the ruins of the West Coast than the Russian culture.

546
01:06:06,210 --> 01:06:11,970
In my other article also write about holding relatives a small one which came into the

547
01:06:11,970 --> 01:06:17,910
real estate in almost girlboss and quickly collected land from small shareholders.

548
01:06:17,910 --> 01:06:27,780
Apart from the land, the villagers were almost immediately deprived of all the resources of the youth of the 1990s in their petty capitalism.

549
01:06:27,780 --> 01:06:34,270
They produced meat, milk store games. They made moonshine and even gushes all that.

550
01:06:34,270 --> 01:06:43,100
The economist from below will evaporate in just a few years after Holden came out on your bet.

551
01:06:43,100 --> 01:06:46,110
What are you seeing happened because of the Soviet remnants?

552
01:06:46,110 --> 01:06:53,190
Not in the sense that there was too much optimism, but because the villagers were not ready to collaborate.

553
01:06:53,190 --> 01:06:59,890
More precisely, the lack of collaboration resulted in the failure to scale up their petty capitalism,

554
01:06:59,890 --> 01:07:07,830
inability to build supply chains and finally inability to defend themselves against dispossession.

555
01:07:07,830 --> 01:07:14,580
The sad conclusion I came to is the disposition apparently awaits all small landholders

556
01:07:14,580 --> 01:07:22,710
in agricultural regions like Moscow West or even less familiar with the payments to cry.

557
01:07:22,710 --> 01:07:28,770
So it's my understanding, and they want to ask to what extent you agree with these three Russians.

558
01:07:28,770 --> 01:07:31,810
So neoliberal capitalism continues to.

559
01:07:31,810 --> 01:07:44,440
See, form all resources, including those suitable for economies from below, what will happen to people who cannot get into mainstream economy?

560
01:07:44,440 --> 01:07:57,150
Will the poor become truly beggars? Finally, what is the role of China and China's farmers or Chinese traders through intermediaries before they work,

561
01:07:57,150 --> 01:08:11,440
the kind of source for survival of rational oracles, but luckily now the real economy and the mechanism of fall for disposition?

562
01:08:11,440 --> 01:08:19,190
Thank you. That's all my questions.

563
01:08:19,190 --> 01:08:26,360
Thanks, Natalia, for these two very challenging and interesting questions,

564
01:08:26,360 --> 01:08:37,580
especially since you've been backed up with rich ethnography that's based on on on a great deal of research and expertise.

565
01:08:37,580 --> 01:08:42,230
I think the best thing would be for Katie and Frank.

566
01:08:42,230 --> 01:08:49,610
In whichever order you want to react spontaneously to these questions, I know they're there.

567
01:08:49,610 --> 01:08:56,780
They are quite deep questions and you probably can't comprehensively address them all at this point.

568
01:08:56,780 --> 01:09:08,300
But if you'd be able to at least comment on on the questions, and I know each each participant's different perspectives.

569
01:09:08,300 --> 01:09:24,360
So who would like to to start us off? Practicality, it's fun to go or you go like, Oh, I'm trying to digest this so much, yeah, yeah, does.

570
01:09:24,360 --> 01:09:26,070
There's a lot of things I think we will.

571
01:09:26,070 --> 01:09:35,790
We won't be able to really, I mean, if we try to answer every question, we would give such and such limited responses.

572
01:09:35,790 --> 01:09:40,580
Let me maybe try with OK.

573
01:09:40,580 --> 01:09:47,430
Just looking at all the really interesting questions I'm I'm I.

574
01:09:47,430 --> 01:09:52,680
I'm going to try and see if I can answer maybe some of the points Madeleine and Allison

575
01:09:52,680 --> 01:10:00,930
were raised in a kind of maybe combine some of the questions I'm thinking about the.

576
01:10:00,930 --> 01:10:11,440
The point that you made about the way we kind of try to avoid the high theory.

577
01:10:11,440 --> 01:10:17,820
I I mean, yeah, I know what would I think about this?

578
01:10:17,820 --> 01:10:22,300
Me trying to remember what my ideals were about this.

579
01:10:22,300 --> 01:10:28,870
I think that's as you said this. That can be a kind of a disjuncture between the theory, high theory and ethnography.

580
01:10:28,870 --> 01:10:37,630
And I think Madeleine kind of raised also this idea of disjuncture between the different kind of views

581
01:10:37,630 --> 01:10:45,640
that we had like going from the more generally to the more the more ethnographic in particular.

582
01:10:45,640 --> 01:10:51,230
And I think maybe these two views, I mean, these two kind of angles are.

583
01:10:51,230 --> 01:11:00,180
May be unavoidable in the work we do as anthropologists, because if we were just describing,

584
01:11:00,180 --> 01:11:07,500
you know, very my new ethnographic specificities without contextualising it,

585
01:11:07,500 --> 01:11:17,390
either in the larger view, all through theory, I think that would be that that would not bring very much for the reader, right?

586
01:11:17,390 --> 01:11:21,940
I would not bring a very important contribution. It would be more like a travel book, just very descriptive.

587
01:11:21,940 --> 01:11:28,730
I think we we I guess. Bye bye.

588
01:11:28,730 --> 01:11:30,410
Not going into theory,

589
01:11:30,410 --> 01:11:42,590
maybe we fell into a different kind of modes of putting things in parallel in terms of looking at trying to contextualise within a larger,

590
01:11:42,590 --> 01:11:49,910
larger context and looking at a low point, I don't know.

591
01:11:49,910 --> 01:11:55,970
I don't know whether you think of that. Could I broken, though, Frank?

592
01:11:55,970 --> 01:12:01,580
I think one thing is that we were actually instructed that this book is a trade book.

593
01:12:01,580 --> 01:12:05,300
It's not even an academic trade book. It's a trade trade book.

594
01:12:05,300 --> 01:12:13,700
And we were told not to to go into anthropological theory because the readership is not supposed to be anthropologists.

595
01:12:13,700 --> 01:12:17,960
It's supposed to be kind of an informative book for the general public.

596
01:12:17,960 --> 01:12:29,150
And so that is certainly for me. That's one reason why I thought we should not not engage with anthropological theory at all, really.

597
01:12:29,150 --> 01:12:40,070
But I was actually really happy to hear Alessandro say he finds that refreshing, but we're glad if that's true.

598
01:12:40,070 --> 01:12:45,080
But in relation to Madeline's point about, on the one hand,

599
01:12:45,080 --> 01:12:54,200
a sort of broad view of political structures as it were and detailed ethnography, I think we did.

600
01:12:54,200 --> 01:12:59,270
At least some of the book tried to bridge that. For example,

601
01:12:59,270 --> 01:13:12,440
in the case of the island where where you do have very detailed accounts of people living there and things that have happened and all contingencies,

602
01:13:12,440 --> 01:13:23,810
I mean, things like the floods the Murray River keeps flooding, sweeps everything away, all the Chinese stuff they're building, it got swept away.

603
01:13:23,810 --> 01:13:27,710
But at the same time, tried to touch into.

604
01:13:27,710 --> 01:13:33,800
As far as we could understand, the political structures on either side, which were were rather different.

605
01:13:33,800 --> 01:13:36,630
I mean, the government, as a local mayor,

606
01:13:36,630 --> 01:13:44,690
a sort of urban structure and for you and on one hand and Barofsky on the other tried to link him to that and

607
01:13:44,690 --> 01:13:53,340
to sort of hint at the point of how those cities on on the edge sort of linking to the bigger structures.

608
01:13:53,340 --> 01:14:00,120
So we tried to make a stab at it may not be very successful, but we had to go.

609
01:14:00,120 --> 01:14:04,540
I think we tried to bring a kind of a general context of the border,

610
01:14:04,540 --> 01:14:11,560
but then then provide details on and showing that the the multi vocal aspect of that.

611
01:14:11,560 --> 01:14:19,060
I mean, the difference between regions is something that is really important in terms of how people perceive the other side.

612
01:14:19,060 --> 01:14:24,370
There's really, I mean, even on the local level, I think that the ethnography about like Irish,

613
01:14:24,370 --> 01:14:30,400
as you can see, some people might feel very positively about China or some might not.

614
01:14:30,400 --> 01:14:37,240
But even even at the individual level, which is kind of interesting, even people that were very eager to go to China,

615
01:14:37,240 --> 01:14:46,450
they would still retain some of the some of the stereotypical kind of imagination of the other.

616
01:14:46,450 --> 01:14:55,780
And I think this is the link between the imagination, something that both you and my men and you, Alessandra, I raised.

617
01:14:55,780 --> 01:15:02,050
I mean, this weather influences like K-pop can be disruptive.

618
01:15:02,050 --> 01:15:10,360
I'm not sure. I think they can easily be accommodated into a more general view of the other.

619
01:15:10,360 --> 01:15:15,040
And the way things representation of the other tend to be filtered through that.

620
01:15:15,040 --> 01:15:25,000
So the representations of in China, the representation of the Russians and to be filtered through a model of understand the

621
01:15:25,000 --> 01:15:29,860
other that we see reflected in the way indigenous populations are represented as well,

622
01:15:29,860 --> 01:15:34,990
in a way that is sanitised, that is accommodated within a general framework,

623
01:15:34,990 --> 01:15:43,030
whether that be the pre-eminent role or position of the Han Chinese remains unaffected.

624
01:15:43,030 --> 01:15:49,690
So in a way, there is maybe a lack of real engagement also on the on the Chinese side.

625
01:15:49,690 --> 01:15:56,270
I feel as this kind of filtered through. So I think this these are some of the.

626
01:15:56,270 --> 01:16:07,550
The examples I really show how you can I mean, we try to to accommodate a larger view on a smaller view and that there does really that does not,

627
01:16:07,550 --> 01:16:12,350
I think at this juncture is really they they feed off each other. I think the local views,

628
01:16:12,350 --> 01:16:21,060
even if they seem to be completely different from from a general idea of the other they self-tanner filtered through and accommodated within that.

629
01:16:21,060 --> 01:16:25,260
I think this. Well,

630
01:16:25,260 --> 01:16:35,940
I'd like to have a make a brief answer to one of Madeleine's questions where you asked about the new sociality and these kind of

631
01:16:35,940 --> 01:16:48,000
links across the border and the sort of theoretical implications of this when at the same time in the book we say these very,

632
01:16:48,000 --> 01:16:55,080
very deep civilizational differences exist between Russia and China.

633
01:16:55,080 --> 01:17:05,670
And you ask if these new ethnic sort of links could be disruptive if I get to write Madeleine or whether they're just exceptions,

634
01:17:05,670 --> 01:17:10,960
that proves the rule. I think.

635
01:17:10,960 --> 01:17:21,100
I think it's a very interesting question, because I think maybe when we we did say that the Russia and China are different all the way down.

636
01:17:21,100 --> 01:17:23,650
That applies to the majority populations,

637
01:17:23,650 --> 01:17:36,730
but I'm not sure that it does about the larger ethnic minorities who I think really do maintain their own history and traditions very,

638
01:17:36,730 --> 01:17:42,880
very actively, and especially so in the last sort of 10 15 years.

639
01:17:42,880 --> 01:17:52,630
I mean, this is in both China and Russia sort of outburst of books sort of genealogies,

640
01:17:52,630 --> 01:18:06,490
revisions of republication of earlier books by by great authors from that ethnicity and so on and immense detailed attention to this.

641
01:18:06,490 --> 01:18:13,180
You know, when I was doing fieldwork in the Kurdistan region, there were every village.

642
01:18:13,180 --> 01:18:16,120
Maybe you're familiar with this, too, Madeleine, from your field.

643
01:18:16,120 --> 01:18:25,240
Every village had somebody who was trying to compile things and getting places and dates and ancestors and all written down,

644
01:18:25,240 --> 01:18:28,400
and they were publishing little local books about it.

645
01:18:28,400 --> 01:18:40,180
And from one sort of area near the sort of edge of the by coast, a barrier to area, the I have a collection of seven mega tomes,

646
01:18:40,180 --> 01:18:52,090
each of them 500 pages of local reminiscences and eminent people from here and the genealogy going to this plan, all that kind of stuff.

647
01:18:52,090 --> 01:19:00,460
And so that's obviously not all patriots and bodegas going for that kind of thing,

648
01:19:00,460 --> 01:19:05,020
but that really does seem to have a significant number of people who do.

649
01:19:05,020 --> 01:19:17,440
And I think it may particularly be people who live in these kind of new perspective, new kind of places.

650
01:19:17,440 --> 01:19:25,780
They're kind of there. They somehow make a living. And, you know, I'm quite a little, you know,

651
01:19:25,780 --> 01:19:34,540
they have a small plot and so a few sheep and whatever it is and what they are interested in is a lot of this stuff.

652
01:19:34,540 --> 01:19:40,300
You know, their own kind of stuff, cultural stuff.

653
01:19:40,300 --> 01:19:47,860
And I thought, in a way, may I'm not sure so sure on the Chinese side, but it may.

654
01:19:47,860 --> 01:19:56,050
I think from what I've seen, where I've worked in China, more in detail is not near the border, but I think it probably does apply.

655
01:19:56,050 --> 01:20:03,160
As Alessandra was pointing out that in China, you could be quite close to the border and it doesn't mean very much,

656
01:20:03,160 --> 01:20:10,930
necessarily, you know, your focus is on your own communities.

657
01:20:10,930 --> 01:20:22,690
And I think that the only people who are exceptions to this are people like the bullets and burgers who actually live on both sides.

658
01:20:22,690 --> 01:20:26,680
I'd like to try and answer Natalia's question.

659
01:20:26,680 --> 01:20:37,180
I'm trying to the seem to be lots of them. I'm trying to get my head around, really.

660
01:20:37,180 --> 01:20:42,340
I mean, what you said? The rocks for board May 21 and 20 and 18, that's really, really interesting.

661
01:20:42,340 --> 01:20:45,120
And I just didn't know all of that.

662
01:20:45,120 --> 01:20:55,810
And so it's new to me, and I had to put together words I could were writing about snowboarding without as much information as you obviously got.

663
01:20:55,810 --> 01:21:03,490
But I think you're quite right that this is not coherent and that if we implied in the book that

664
01:21:03,490 --> 01:21:11,320
the Moscow kind of structural picture works all the way down to the everybody on the edges,

665
01:21:11,320 --> 01:21:17,890
that's wrong. And you're quite you're quite right. And we shouldn't have implied that if we did, I hope.

666
01:21:17,890 --> 01:21:27,910
I hope we didn't, really. So I think the fact that there are different views on this and there are different standpoints

667
01:21:27,910 --> 01:21:35,500
from from different positions like the governor who region or who may be a temporary person,

668
01:21:35,500 --> 01:21:45,490
but sort of municipal heads who made them much more permanent. These are all that kind of thing would make a huge difference in people's

669
01:21:45,490 --> 01:21:53,470
attitudes and what they want to get out of things like the resources from Utah,

670
01:21:53,470 --> 01:22:06,250
if they can tune into it at all or their attitudes to the Chinese kind of agri business is sitting there amongst them.

671
01:22:06,250 --> 01:22:14,900
So I really do agree with you, it's not coherent. But if you're asking me to predict what's going to happen there, you know much more than I do.

672
01:22:14,900 --> 01:22:30,470
Natalia, you better tell us. Frank, did you have any further thoughts on what was said before?

673
01:22:30,470 --> 01:22:35,110
Uh, yes, I, I,

674
01:22:35,110 --> 01:22:40,300
I I've been very interested in what Madeline said about the individual fields because that's

675
01:22:40,300 --> 01:22:48,280
something I've been kind of working on and looking at a multi-sensory all kind of views of borders.

676
01:22:48,280 --> 01:22:53,050
I've been interested in haptic and touch in the auditory.

677
01:22:53,050 --> 01:22:54,220
And I think you're right.

678
01:22:54,220 --> 01:23:03,520
My let I maybe I don't know whether we've made enough of a point to them that I think the fact that it's really about reality, I mean,

679
01:23:03,520 --> 01:23:14,140
optic is really I mean, the vision vision in terms of senses is the one that really stays the most remote is the least proximate, all the senses.

680
01:23:14,140 --> 01:23:21,790
And I think that's that says a lot about the relationship between the two because everything is mediated at a distance.

681
01:23:21,790 --> 01:23:31,000
I was really kind of surprised when I was in regulations in particular that you would not hear Chinese music.

682
01:23:31,000 --> 01:23:38,950
There's actually there's I remember looking at the movies that were at the movie theatre and they were,

683
01:23:38,950 --> 01:23:46,990
you know, either Russian or Western, and there was very little engagement with Chinese culture.

684
01:23:46,990 --> 01:23:51,040
The only the only exception to that would be food.

685
01:23:51,040 --> 01:23:58,660
Food is actually was a big thing, and that's very proximal. So again, it kind of complicates the issue.

686
01:23:58,660 --> 01:24:02,890
But it's true that the first the first interaction that you see between the two is

687
01:24:02,890 --> 01:24:07,810
really kind of a lack of interaction because it's really mediated through the eyes.

688
01:24:07,810 --> 01:24:12,400
But that doesn't mean that is the only thing happening.

689
01:24:12,400 --> 01:24:16,660
I mean, I I think it was maybe I mean,

690
01:24:16,660 --> 01:24:26,710
I remember the being surprised by the number of Chinese restaurant eating Black Irish and or really kind of there was a lot is very popular food.

691
01:24:26,710 --> 01:24:35,770
People enjoy going to China for the food. So there's really engagement at that level in a way that is very kind of a non

692
01:24:35,770 --> 01:24:39,680
mediated in a way like having a kind of direct engagement for the Chinese side.

693
01:24:39,680 --> 01:24:48,850
I think there is I mean, in particular, you can you do hear Russian music and you have some accommodation made for Russian food,

694
01:24:48,850 --> 01:24:57,790
but I don't know to what extent is I think it's really kind of it's really fodder for the Russian audience.

695
01:24:57,790 --> 01:25:00,460
It's not something that it's not for Chinese consumption.

696
01:25:00,460 --> 01:25:10,690
So I think again, the experience of the Chinese with with Russia is also mediated through vision, especially because,

697
01:25:10,690 --> 01:25:16,330
you know, you have these bulbs going on the river, just looking at China and Russia and then coming back.

698
01:25:16,330 --> 01:25:27,910
So but yeah, and I guess in terms of food stuffs, you do have things sold in L.A. for for domestic tourists,

699
01:25:27,910 --> 01:25:33,500
but is not really kind of a big engagement with that. So I think I think that was a really interesting point that you raised on something.

700
01:25:33,500 --> 01:25:38,560
I I I don't I can't recall how much we make of it in the book.

701
01:25:38,560 --> 01:25:41,900
It's definitely an interesting point.

702
01:25:41,900 --> 01:25:51,160
There's so many other things that we should be responding to, but I I think it's kind of difficult to do that in the allocated time.

703
01:25:51,160 --> 01:26:01,310
So I don't know whether maybe we can just email you directly once we've had time to reflect a bit more to respond to your questions.

704
01:26:01,310 --> 01:26:10,100
Yes, what I was, I was thinking that we could you I could help curate these responses and send them around to you.

705
01:26:10,100 --> 01:26:21,140
And that this could be turned into some sort of more extended written forum or something that that could generate interest in the book because,

706
01:26:21,140 --> 01:26:28,370
well, it's a U.S. carrier. It's a trade book, mostly, but it's I think it has a lot of repercussions.

707
01:26:28,370 --> 01:26:38,270
And for anthropologists interested in this area, I was wondering, Carrie, what you thought about Natalia's second point,

708
01:26:38,270 --> 01:26:44,690
which was that this dispossession, I think, she said, awaits everyone in the Far East,

709
01:26:44,690 --> 01:26:55,250
that this this story that you've told of, of people, you know, following Black that the first 30 years they've been able to to kind of leave,

710
01:26:55,250 --> 01:27:02,590
OK, and these somewhat empty lands or even, you know, small scale agriculture.

711
01:27:02,590 --> 01:27:15,340
But but there's a certain model of capitalism that's know in Russia now that's going to so we kind of growth that not left you.

712
01:27:15,340 --> 01:27:19,950
I know you're not predicting the future, but there's certain predictive qualities in your work.

713
01:27:19,950 --> 01:27:30,970
Do you see the the trajectory or the way things are going with the, you know, the informal economy there?

714
01:27:30,970 --> 01:27:41,840
Well, as I remember it, the abductor account was actually itself quite chronologically.

715
01:27:41,840 --> 01:27:51,730
And he expressed a changes in the way those kind of that hunting ground idea worked.

716
01:27:51,730 --> 01:28:07,600
And I think he does end up by arguing that the big companies kind of tend to kind of blot out what else is going on,

717
01:28:07,600 --> 01:28:15,520
but they only do it by actually squeezing out the sort of middle rank companies,

718
01:28:15,520 --> 01:28:26,290
which then turn into more egregious and potentially illegal kind of activities.

719
01:28:26,290 --> 01:28:31,210
And I how can I predict?

720
01:28:31,210 --> 01:28:37,360
I've no idea, really, but I think there could be a process on the one hand of growing poverty,

721
01:28:37,360 --> 01:28:44,260
which I think is what Natalia's suggesting a real poverty there,

722
01:28:44,260 --> 01:28:56,380
but also a continuation of the of that process, of the more kind of you've got some mega structures that are sort of hanging over you.

723
01:28:56,380 --> 01:29:00,910
There will be things squeezed out at the edges. There will be things that won't fit into it.

724
01:29:00,910 --> 01:29:04,210
There'll be people who refuse to work in it.

725
01:29:04,210 --> 01:29:14,170
And I think the example of the fishing show that to some extent that that there are just going to be people who

726
01:29:14,170 --> 01:29:21,790
have kind of gotten used to doing it outside the bounds of what should be the kind of regular way of doing things.

727
01:29:21,790 --> 01:29:33,420
And they're pretty adept at doing it. And I I don't think that that is going to end as far as I can make out.

728
01:29:33,420 --> 01:29:38,610
I don't know what do you think, Natalia, actually?

729
01:29:38,610 --> 01:29:46,530
I think that we can tell about the Russian forest, but the wall, I mean, the territory is huge.

730
01:29:46,530 --> 01:29:48,060
There are different processes.

731
01:29:48,060 --> 01:30:00,780
If we focus on a village, I mentioned it is very specific because it's very comfortable, it's very productive for growing soybeans.

732
01:30:00,780 --> 01:30:12,180
And you know, that's working as a global commodity. But if we focus on some small villages somewhere in the middle of nowhere, yeah,

733
01:30:12,180 --> 01:30:20,760
actually, people still have a lot of basis for their economies from below as you well.

734
01:30:20,760 --> 01:30:31,260
So I assume that the territory will proceed to be more and more like different territory,

735
01:30:31,260 --> 01:30:41,580
which adjusted to cities or territories which have some roads a little bit, then an a lot of roads.

736
01:30:41,580 --> 01:30:48,150
However, there are some connectivity, so if the settlement homes have.

737
01:30:48,150 --> 01:30:53,730
Settlements have roads and access to site of them.

738
01:30:53,730 --> 01:31:00,090
We will see real beggars there or just a migration, people just leave the spaces.

739
01:31:00,090 --> 01:31:13,800
The problem with there would not be villages. I mean, look, villagers as we used to be used to meet, but other religions probably would be different.

740
01:31:13,800 --> 01:31:20,790
So your prediction is not a good for the scholars.

741
01:31:20,790 --> 01:31:30,690
However, the the reality which we are now observing is changing so fast because of these advanced

742
01:31:30,690 --> 01:31:40,320
development areas and also because of the new to thinking that forest the hectare we you also.

743
01:31:40,320 --> 01:31:49,350
Oh yes, for sure. You wrote the well, the mentioned about this, but I mean, the audience also know about the new there.

744
01:31:49,350 --> 01:31:51,810
So that's also changed the situation.

745
01:31:51,810 --> 01:32:03,150
There are a lot of people who would like to go would like to leave somewhere in the middle of nowhere and that that's actually not the process.

746
01:32:03,150 --> 01:32:08,610
So. Yes, I think I agree, I think that's very interesting.

747
01:32:08,610 --> 01:32:14,160
I mean, in a burrito, which was, I know better than any other place there are,

748
01:32:14,160 --> 01:32:18,990
there are small Buddhist monasteries which largely have got around them,

749
01:32:18,990 --> 01:32:26,190
whole little camps and settlements in little villages of people from Moscow and over in the

750
01:32:26,190 --> 01:32:33,330
West who want to go and live in a Buddhist environment in nature and all that is happening.

751
01:32:33,330 --> 01:32:37,590
But I also think that it's ethnically very diverse.

752
01:32:37,590 --> 01:32:46,980
You mentioned kind of class differences, but I think if we look at people like idiots,

753
01:32:46,980 --> 01:32:55,860
I think that their village life may continue quite in a sort of not a beggarly way that

754
01:32:55,860 --> 01:33:03,390
they will manage to keep things going because they are so much better at collaboration.

755
01:33:03,390 --> 01:33:08,820
You mentioned lack of collaboration, but some of these ethnic groups are really good at it,

756
01:33:08,820 --> 01:33:19,830
and they just have that way of operating with their kin networks and the cousin who comes in and does that and all this kind of thing.

757
01:33:19,830 --> 01:33:30,780
And it it really works. OK, so you can have I've seen it an old couple who are really physically unable to do a lot of the jobs that

758
01:33:30,780 --> 01:33:39,210
are required for them to keep the plot going and the cow and the firewood for winter and all of that.

759
01:33:39,210 --> 01:33:43,800
But they managed to do it because they were in a kind of entire collaborative environment.

760
01:33:43,800 --> 01:33:53,520
And this includes somebody who will drop down from the city at the weekend and bring something to them or,

761
01:33:53,520 --> 01:33:59,030
you know, exchange relations with a lot of people in the village, that sort of thing.

762
01:33:59,030 --> 01:34:06,140
So I think I don't see that dying out exactly, but I think it just be specific.

763
01:34:06,140 --> 01:34:08,570
I agree with the idea.

764
01:34:08,570 --> 01:34:16,590
Could I just say, Madeleine, Madeleine needs to leave just now, so we thank her then and we'll continue the conversation with Madeleine.

765
01:34:16,590 --> 01:34:21,460
Another point, but thank you. Yes, I apologise. I want to do with childcare.

766
01:34:21,460 --> 01:34:26,060
Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you. You know, right?

767
01:34:26,060 --> 01:34:35,040
But I think we can talk for another 15 minutes or so. So, Natalie, you were just responding to Katie.

768
01:34:35,040 --> 01:34:47,940
I just wanted to agree that the ethnic diversity doesn't matter for entirely into the Russian forests or Siberian islands.

769
01:34:47,940 --> 01:34:53,990
Mm-Hmm. Yes, they are different in human relations.

770
01:34:53,990 --> 01:35:03,200
And will they give people? Yeah, I mean,

771
01:35:03,200 --> 01:35:15,710
one other question that I thought we may discuss was Alessandra talked about the Chinese view of nature and there's a chapter on resources.

772
01:35:15,710 --> 01:35:20,960
And in the book, frankly, I think you were the author of an.

773
01:35:20,960 --> 01:35:27,050
I mean, one of the things that I was wondering is, you know, there's this talk of is there are Res Publica,

774
01:35:27,050 --> 01:35:31,190
a sure thing between can there be a sure thing between Russia and China?

775
01:35:31,190 --> 01:35:40,500
And obviously as we we sit on this precipice of the 21st century and people are wondering what the the ecological commons and famously wrote,

776
01:35:40,500 --> 01:35:46,460
the man said that he imagined that that Russia could be in the 21st century.

777
01:35:46,460 --> 01:35:55,490
This superpower of equality with its this wonderful, well, goodness and there was no need to to exploit boys.

778
01:35:55,490 --> 01:36:01,910
So can you see any crossover between Chinese models of nature and and Russian ones?

779
01:36:01,910 --> 01:36:07,940
Or is it anything you see a big ecology thing?

780
01:36:07,940 --> 01:36:22,620
Um. Well, there seems to be, I think, maybe a lack of infrastructure or context in order for them to really collaborate.

781
01:36:22,620 --> 01:36:30,820
I think the collaboration between them has been successful for things like the protection of the Tigers, for instance,

782
01:36:30,820 --> 01:36:41,220
for the creation of creation of large parks that are done that need to be then that need to be kind of across

783
01:36:41,220 --> 01:36:49,110
the two states and advantage they have in terms of collaboration is that because things are so centralised.

784
01:36:49,110 --> 01:36:54,180
If you have really kind of the two heads of states kind of pushing for something that is

785
01:36:54,180 --> 01:37:03,220
easier for things to happen across across the border rather than in in in other places,

786
01:37:03,220 --> 01:37:09,660
there would be a multiplicity of actors, there would be different stakeholders with different opinions.

787
01:37:09,660 --> 01:37:18,150
So I think this has been kind of this way of maybe kind of a more authoritarian model can be useful in a way.

788
01:37:18,150 --> 01:37:23,520
But yes, it is. Still, there are different pressures on both sides, I think.

789
01:37:23,520 --> 01:37:32,740
I mean, there's more pressure on the Chinese side to to use the land in a more in a more productive way and not aggressively necessarily,

790
01:37:32,740 --> 01:37:46,350
but in a more more intensively. Whereas in Russia, they can be less less of a demographic pressure, I guess, two two years down the line.

791
01:37:46,350 --> 01:37:54,710
So I don't know whether that answers your question, and it's not that you got something more specific in mind.

792
01:37:54,710 --> 01:38:10,000
No, so that's that's great, thanks for. Well, we have a let's let's have a question from the charts.

793
01:38:10,000 --> 01:38:17,140
Would you like to ask this, or shall I read the notes? What would you prefer?

794
01:38:17,140 --> 01:38:21,940
Bill, can you hear me? Yeah. I don't know. Oh, OK.

795
01:38:21,940 --> 01:38:27,010
I don't mind either way, to be honest. Baby, please, please, please, please don't.

796
01:38:27,010 --> 01:38:31,870
Right? OK. So I just have a. So give you some background because I did.

797
01:38:31,870 --> 01:38:35,770
And I'm from the northeast of China, myself at Jilin province.

798
01:38:35,770 --> 01:38:41,560
And then I did a little bit of kind of a pilot research at the border Wenchuan city,

799
01:38:41,560 --> 01:38:48,460
which lies between the three countries border China and Russia, and also North Korea,

800
01:38:48,460 --> 01:38:55,930
and the my research was mainly to detect a North Korean kind of interactions with the on the borderline

801
01:38:55,930 --> 01:39:02,680
with China and how the North Koreans sent labours and especially the female labourers to China,

802
01:39:02,680 --> 01:39:06,820
worked for the Chinese factories, etc. and then a one phenomenon.

803
01:39:06,820 --> 01:39:11,170
When I was there, I noticed this. So most of the trade, cross-border trade,

804
01:39:11,170 --> 01:39:17,920
the loss of actually trade between the North Korea and the side and also the Chinese side and

805
01:39:17,920 --> 01:39:23,140
the most of them done activities are actually done by the Chinese ethnic minority people,

806
01:39:23,140 --> 01:39:33,310
the Chinese Koreans. So my question is, in what way if I can think about the Chinese histories and how how these Korean,

807
01:39:33,310 --> 01:39:40,360
especially these regional histories, how this region was formed and then the cuts between the different countries?

808
01:39:40,360 --> 01:39:51,790
And it seems the Chinese government control all these type of regions very much in response to the ethnic minority people who occupies this region.

809
01:39:51,790 --> 01:39:56,890
And then another way to say is, um, either way,

810
01:39:56,890 --> 01:40:04,240
the Chinese government across the history or Chinese recalls across history seems to leave this frontier red

811
01:40:04,240 --> 01:40:13,720
zone as kind of a buffer zone against the potential non-Chinese going to be invasions or Chinese expansions.

812
01:40:13,720 --> 01:40:20,350
So in what way related to the theme of this emptiness is intentionally done.

813
01:40:20,350 --> 01:40:28,420
This reaches left empty in order to to maintain control of the central goals of the heartland of China.

814
01:40:28,420 --> 01:40:37,810
And then ironically, this kind of emptiness leaves the free that of the local ethnic minority people

815
01:40:37,810 --> 01:40:43,210
in China to actually do to trade or to to organise their own social life.

816
01:40:43,210 --> 01:40:48,940
That's my main kind of ancestral graphic kind of question relating to this theme.

817
01:40:48,940 --> 01:40:52,720
And then in my methodological one is mainly just because I did the research,

818
01:40:52,720 --> 01:40:57,910
my research it my main doctoral research is on Chinese engagement in Africa.

819
01:40:57,910 --> 01:41:02,590
And then one of the problems I always encounter when I was doing research is how to

820
01:41:02,590 --> 01:41:10,060
relate to Chinese migrants social life everyday lives on the ground related to a higher,

821
01:41:10,060 --> 01:41:15,700
very much macro scale of a China-Africa international relations.

822
01:41:15,700 --> 01:41:21,190
So how can we do as democratic research on international relations?

823
01:41:21,190 --> 01:41:28,000
Mm hmm. Well, can I respond to that? I think that's a really, really interesting.

824
01:41:28,000 --> 01:41:38,800
I think, um yeah, I think you may be right about this buffer zone idea in relation to China and the border.

825
01:41:38,800 --> 01:41:44,530
And it may be why, for example, in the case of the area around for yuan,

826
01:41:44,530 --> 01:41:54,910
they've created a really very extensive what you call it, a kind of nature, nature reserve sort of thing.

827
01:41:54,910 --> 01:42:04,930
It's it's for preserving marshes and that kind of thing, which is expanded and now includes the Chinese half of the island.

828
01:42:04,930 --> 01:42:16,780
And in a way that leaves it empty. But I'm in my experience, I'm not sure that it needs that much opportunity for local people.

829
01:42:16,780 --> 01:42:24,030
Well, you mentioned trade, of course, the North North Korean border.

830
01:42:24,030 --> 01:42:30,190
I don't know how much is going on across the across the river.

831
01:42:30,190 --> 01:42:37,560
I the may be I mean, I think this some illegal fishing in that kind of thing.

832
01:42:37,560 --> 01:42:44,250
But it's very difficult to document and I don't get the impression that there's immense

833
01:42:44,250 --> 01:42:51,630
sort of the fact of there being some clear land creates that much opportunity,

834
01:42:51,630 --> 01:43:02,910
maybe illegal hunting, but I don't know. And I also think that the Chinese government policy with regard to indigenous peoples is changing.

835
01:43:02,910 --> 01:43:16,590
And we see this in relation to Inner Mongolia, where they're insisting that even primary school children now should have all the lessons in Chinese.

836
01:43:16,590 --> 01:43:22,860
And I think there are parallel things in other parts of Southwest China, Tibet and so on.

837
01:43:22,860 --> 01:43:28,560
And I think the the very broadly speaking,

838
01:43:28,560 --> 01:43:43,890
the earlier model in which you have a China as a sort of multi-national nation is gradually changing into a sort of homogenous Chinese nation,

839
01:43:43,890 --> 01:43:56,310
much more homogenous with just less opportunity, less funding, less place for all the different cultures inside.

840
01:43:56,310 --> 01:44:09,210
And quite a lot of pressure for the generations to be increasingly signified that that's what the impression I get.

841
01:44:09,210 --> 01:44:16,060
I just to add to that, I think there is really kind of a hardening of borders in that sense in China.

842
01:44:16,060 --> 01:44:23,880
The point you made about the kind of ethnic groups kind of similar to the ones on the other

843
01:44:23,880 --> 01:44:28,740
side being used as kind of intermediaries in a way kind of a kind of a liminal space.

844
01:44:28,740 --> 01:44:33,480
So that's something I you don't have with the the Russian border.

845
01:44:33,480 --> 01:44:46,200
I mean, you have small groups, I mean, smaller groups like the various other moguls who have taken that kind of role.

846
01:44:46,200 --> 01:44:52,170
But you don't have like a large Russian population on the Chinese side, the way you would have, you know,

847
01:44:52,170 --> 01:44:59,220
kind of substantial Korean minority in China that would be able to take on that role and be fully bilingual.

848
01:44:59,220 --> 01:45:04,380
But yes, I think there's there seems to be kind of a signing of the border in the sense of there.

849
01:45:04,380 --> 01:45:09,720
There's a drive towards a more modern as a state.

850
01:45:09,720 --> 01:45:23,630
I think so. I agree. I would agree with Carrie, though. Well, the thing we we have time for one more question, which comes from for lawyer Artur,

851
01:45:23,630 --> 01:45:30,100
what would you like to ask your question or shall I read it out? OK, I'll read.

852
01:45:30,100 --> 01:45:40,420
OK, so reload your rates, your book, your book does indeed go against the new Cold War mentality, where Russian and China,

853
01:45:40,420 --> 01:45:46,900
Russia and China are portrayed as the ultimate villains plotting against the Western democracies behind their backs.

854
01:45:46,900 --> 01:45:54,010
However, there is truth in increasing cooperation between China and Russia and beyond in post-Soviet countries.

855
01:45:54,010 --> 01:45:59,290
In my view, would say in Belarus, which is an important trade hub on the way to Europe,

856
01:45:59,290 --> 01:46:05,650
Chinese is a popular language to study in schools and some ATMs of Chinese language.

857
01:46:05,650 --> 01:46:09,540
Chinese agricultural companies are present in Ukraine.

858
01:46:09,540 --> 01:46:16,990
If, in addition to the border, you were to choose another or other field sites to study Russia China relations.

859
01:46:16,990 --> 01:46:33,610
What would you choose? Well, one of the people in our project was a Chinese expert on on Russia who who hails from Shanghai,

860
01:46:33,610 --> 01:46:46,270
and he was telling us that actually Chinese government and UN companies prefer not to engage, particularly in this border region, which they do.

861
01:46:46,270 --> 01:46:57,190
They don't see us having much perspective, and it's full of too much bureaucracy and hindrances of every kind.

862
01:46:57,190 --> 01:47:02,320
And they prefer, in fact, to go to parts of western Russia.

863
01:47:02,320 --> 01:47:07,630
I mean, he didn't mention Belarus anyway.

864
01:47:07,630 --> 01:47:15,040
I think the implication of what he's saying is that a large amount of Chinese investment in Russia is nowhere near this border.

865
01:47:15,040 --> 01:47:22,000
It's somewhere else. It's in areas where it looks more kind of economically promising.

866
01:47:22,000 --> 01:47:36,830
And because it's sort of bigger scale, it's less hampered by sort of local kind of bureaucratic complications that that's what he was saying.

867
01:47:36,830 --> 01:47:40,850
And in terms of where we could do research on Russia and China,

868
01:47:40,850 --> 01:47:51,760
what a personally Central Asia think would be kind of interesting because they're both invested in that kind of third space.

869
01:47:51,760 --> 01:47:55,510
And I think it would be interesting to see what's happening there in terms of

870
01:47:55,510 --> 01:48:03,210
how people feel about this kind of shift in kind of geopolitical orientation.

871
01:48:03,210 --> 01:48:07,290
Now. But.

872
01:48:07,290 --> 01:48:11,010
Yeah, in Eastern Europe can also be very interesting.

873
01:48:11,010 --> 01:48:25,350
Eastern and Central Europe gesture to to see a kind of be our I was kind of a the old kind of connexions with the former Soviet Union.

874
01:48:25,350 --> 01:48:29,350
That would be kind of interesting to. Well,

875
01:48:29,350 --> 01:48:37,350
I think that's very fitting final comment to to end our discussion today on which is how this

876
01:48:37,350 --> 01:48:43,330
this book on the Edge is going to initiate and inaugurate a whole research agenda about Russia,

877
01:48:43,330 --> 01:48:52,610
China, relations and anthropology. Hopefully, at least this contributing to my current project in the Russian Far East,

878
01:48:52,610 --> 01:49:02,680
and I thank you for engaging with our conference theme in such a generous way and sharing that book with us.

879
01:49:02,680 --> 01:49:15,250
And I hope that it reaches an anthropological audience and a broader audience in the world than they are.

880
01:49:15,250 --> 01:49:23,380
Because, of course, is one of the most important topics in the world today and with certain alliances

881
01:49:23,380 --> 01:49:28,900
or certain hostilities that the Alexandru was intimating in his comments.

882
01:49:28,900 --> 01:49:35,830
It's essential there are a more nuanced perspective is out there.

883
01:49:35,830 --> 01:49:45,790
And I think that that's one thing that this book really is a wonderful example of public anthropology with so being willing that on its sleeve.

884
01:49:45,790 --> 01:49:51,310
So with that, I encourage everyone to the by and read this book and share the world.

885
01:49:51,310 --> 01:50:03,010
And we look forward to coming out in November, and I will connect frank and carry with these these wonderful responses from the tally,

886
01:50:03,010 --> 01:50:12,280
Alessandra and Madeline, and look forward to more publicity being generated for the book, as well as more research ideas coming out of it.

887
01:50:12,280 --> 01:50:16,990
So I would conclude our discussion with that.

888
01:50:16,990 --> 01:50:21,430
There's another final discussion in another in this room.

889
01:50:21,430 --> 01:50:25,210
OK, we'll stay on this link, but that's all for now.

890
01:50:25,210 --> 01:50:33,730
A bit a bit this book. So thank you very much, Katie and Frank for your time and Alexandra Natalie for reading the book.

891
01:50:33,730 --> 01:50:37,570
Thanks. Thank you for setting it up. We're really grateful.

892
01:50:37,570 --> 01:50:50,964
It's kind of you. Yeah. McCrone. It's my pleasure.